Labour ‘irresponsible’ for walking away from Budget deal, says Plaid
Martin Shipton
The Labour Party has been branded “irresponsible” for walking away from an offer of £80m of extra funding for Additional Learning Needs proposed by the Welsh Government as part of discussions on the Supplementary Budget.
Responding to reports that Labour have rejected an offer which would have secured £80m of additional funding, evenly split between the current financial year and next, Plaid Cymru MS Kiera Marshall said that “parents, pupils and teachers will rightly question Labour’s commitment to this issue”, branding their rejection of the constructive offer from the Plaid Cymru Welsh Government which comes despite the challenging financial picture as “irresponsible.”
The measures set out in the Supplementary Budget include £145m towards cutting waiting lists, £55m towards the most transformational childcare offer anywhere in the UK, £15m towards rolling out free school meals in secondary schools and £20m capital funding towards social homes.
Caerdydd Penarth MS Ms Marshall said: “It is deeply irresponsible for Labour to walk away from such a constructive offer of £80m towards ALN by our Plaid Cymru Government.
“Despite the financial challenges they inherited, the Welsh Government has worked constructively to bring a proposal to the table based on a strategic approach to making the ALN system more sustainable.
“Parents, pupils and teachers will rightly question Labour’s commitment to this issue now that they have chosen to reject what would have been a very positive step forward for those campaigning on this issue.
“By voting against the Supplementary Budget, not only would Labour be voting against £145m for the NHS, £55m towards funded childcare and £15m to roll our free school meals in secondary schools – all things they claim to support – they would be exposing the fact that they would rather score political points than act as a responsible opposition.”
Labour rejects the claim that it has walked away from talks.
In a letter to First Minister Rhun ap Iorwerth, Labour group interim leader Ken Skates said he’s grateful for “the constructive discussions on this matter” and that he “recognise [s] the movement and progress made in recent days”.
He added: “The latest suggested quantum of investment for additional learning needs discussed between our parties continues to fall short of this mark. As already mentioned, I recognise there has been progress and movement in recent days. In that same spirit, I would urge the government to continue that movement and make at least £100m available for investment in ALN so that we can then help deliver a positive supplementary budget for Wales.”
A Welsh Labour spokesperson added: “There wasn’t a penny on the table for additional learning needs until Welsh Labour fought for it.
“£40m this year falls far short of what children and young people with additional learning needs require.
“Schools, teaching unions and councils are clear in their support for our position. We will not back down.
“This is about getting the best possible deal for vulnerable children and young people.”
If no deal can be reached before Tuesday, the Welsh Government will almost certainly lose the vote. In such an event, Finance Minister Elin Jones will have to draw up a new supplementary budget in the autumn.
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.
Get more trusted Welsh news
Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News to see more of our journalism.
Nothing will change. A bunch of political neanderthals who spare not one thought for Wales and its problems.
Poor show from Ken Skates, do they really not care about the stability of our Senedd and government, and the advance of the far right here? I get the election result is a big shock, but don’t be sore losers. We wouldn’t see antics like this from Mark Drakeford even in opposition, for all his faults he understood that the weight of our responsibility is more important than playing silly politics. If Labour think this is the way back, good luck to them, they need it.
I’m no fan of Ken Skates. Anyone who’s content to be a branch manager and says Welsh Labour isn’t sustainable without finance from the English party will never get my vote. But Plaid is being disingenuous if it thinks that the role of other parties is to fall in line with their policies. They’ve only been in office for a couple of months already they’re showing signs of entitlement. Plaid have offered £80m, Skates wants £100m. It’s clear that he’s negotiating. There are still three days to sort this. I’d be surprised if they can’t work something out.
I agree. And ken skates has a valid point. The leader of Wrexham council has said this amounts to a budget cut to Wrexham council and will result in service cuts and tax rises across the board. The ALN spending is statutory, they can’t avoid spending the money
Six form politics. Plaid entered into a minority government. Conducting budget discussions across the airwaves is hardly like to engender friends
Spot on.
That is exactly what Labour did all the time when they were in government.
If this additional funding isn’t used will it be clawed back by Whitehall. Will opposition parties have to face their constituents knowing they are in the same camp as Governor Redwood and the Johnson regime.
Seem to remember this exact argument in reverse between Labour and Plaid in the 2024/25 talks.
The real problem here is poor legislation in the first place. The ALNET bill – brought forward by Labour but supported by Plaid at the time – wasn’t properly costed. School and Council budgets are now paying the price.
Welsh Labour seem to be fessing up by insisting that the exact same funding England needs to fix their broken system is needed in Wales.
Is this what we’re going to get over the next four years? Labour getting into bed with Deform and the Tories? At least we’re getting to see their true colours now.
Labour behaving like traitors to Cymru?
Well I never…..
Labour is trying to be smart by playing with children and NHS patients lifes for party political point scoring and quite frankly it’s sadistic, Labour has shown their true colours and it’s very immature, I would have expected this from the right-wing parties but to come from Labour too, it just shows that they are all cut from the same unionist cloth.