Labour MP rejects devolution Bill over fears for Cornwall’s minority status
A Labour MP has said he cannot support his party’s flagship devolution Bill as its proposals could create an “unholy alliance” between Cornwall and Devon.
Perran Moon (Camborne and Redruth) said any plans to create a mayoral strategic authority between Cornwall and its neighbour were “blatant discrimination” and rode roughshod over Cornish national minority status.
Mr Moon, who was elected to the seat in last year’s general election, said it would rupture trust between Cornwall and Westminster for generations, and bolster support for Cornish nationalism.
He raised questions over whether Devonian taxpayers would be happy to subsidise Cornish language lessons and road signs under the mooted arrangements.
Mr Moon said: “Because of our national minority status, Cornwall will never, Cornwall cannot ever, join a mayoral combined authority.
“No matter what ministerial pressure is applied.
“Whether through the withdrawal of economic development funding, or the prevention of access to social housing funding.
“None of this will make us compromise our national minority status, because frankly it is discriminatory to do so.”
The MP, who served on the Bill Committee debating potential changes to the proposed legislation, said he was upset Labour had brought it forward.
National minority status
He said it did not take into account the national minority status awarded to Cornwall by the UK government in 2014.
It put them on a similar footing to the Scots, Welsh and Irish and, according to the Council of Europe’s framework, meant Cornish people have the right to “preserve… and develop their distinct culture and identity”.
The English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill would create combined mayoral authorities to replace councils that would oversee key areas, including transport, skills and employment, and housing.
There are fears that those who do not take part in the reorganisation and get mayors will lose out on extra funding.
“I have to say that it is disappointing to me that a party I love could bring forward a Bill that ignores the wishes of Cornwall, and what national minority status actually means,” Mr Moon said.
“To those who mock and disparage and denigrate Cornwall’s constitutional position on this island, I say this to you: if you try to ensnare us on an unholy alliance with a part of England, it will rebound negatively.
“The impact and the consequences of an unamended Bill will be felt across Cornwall for decades… the relationship with Westminster would decline, and the current simmering resentment and disillusion would be baked in.
“Regrettably it would not surprise me if the calls for full fifth national status for Cornwall will simply grow if this Bill passes unamended.”
‘Crossroads’
Urging ministers to reconsider, Mr Moon continued: “We stand at a crossroads.
“I urge ministers to be bold, be flexible, and empower our communities.
“Do not impose their ideological, governance template on us.
“If unamended, the impact of this Bill is that Cornwall would be the only part of the United Kingdom locked out of access to the highest level of devolution, based solely on who we are.
“That is rank, blatant discrimination, and I cannot and I will not accept it.
“Ministers know all this, because we’ve had several discussions and meetings to look at the risks, and to that end, with a heavy heart, I have to say to ministers that in its current unamended state, I will not be supporting the English devolution Bill.”
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.
Despite its ‘county’ status Kernow is a constituant nation of the UK. The UK Government should respect that position
Huw is right. London must show some respect. I am glad to hear that links between Cymru and Kernow are rapidly growing in the fields of business, trade, culture, the arts, etc. There is a healthy two nations dialogue which we should all tap into and give our full support.
I mean… it could… if Devon were to be considered Cornwall. Just call it Dumnonia it’ll be like old times.
This would mean expanding the minority status it would potentially mean the resources and ability to seek greater devolution.
I don’t think people from Devon would in principle object to funding Cornish language lessons. There might not be that much uptake initially but I can certainly see it spreading eventually, so the cost burden would be relatively small.
Just call the combined authority Kernow, update all signs with Cornish and teach everyone Cornish. The former county of Devon is mainly second homes for Londoners so everyone’s happy.
So a bunch of blockheaded English politicians are dictating to a Celtic Nation again. Ever it was thus 🙄 That doesn’t change the feelings of frustration, anger and resentment towards others exercising power over us. I’d had enough of this years ago and nowadays I’m just seething with rage 😠😡🤬