Labour will not be ‘forgiven in Wales over Port Talbot steel closure’ – Plaid Cymru

Labour will not be forgiven in Wales for allowing the closure of Port Talbot’s blast furnaces, Plaid Cymru leader Rhun ap Iorwerth has said, as the party stepped up its attack on Keir Starmer’s leadership ahead of next year’s Senedd election.
Traditional steel production in Wales was brought to an end in September last year as the last blast furnace at Tata Steels Port Talbot plant was shut down.
An estimated 2,000 jobs are expected to be lost at the plant, which will transition to greener steel production from 2027.
Speaking on Sunday Morning with Trevor Phillips, Mr ap Iorwerth accused the Labour leader of showing no interest in Wales’ “specific and particular needs” and said voters remained angry about the loss of virgin steelmaking capacity at Tata’s Port Talbot works.
‘Real anger’
“Port Talbot would be perhaps the most glaring example where we lost virgin steelmaking capacity at the Port Talbot steelworks – real anger about that, a process started by the Conservatives, of course, finished off by Labour,” he said.
“At the same time they were letting Port Talbot go, they decided that Scunthorpe was deserving of Government help to step in to save primary steel making. They will not be forgotten, forgiven in Wales for doing that.”
His comments comes as Plaid seeks to position itself as the leading alternative to both Labour and Reform UK ahead of the May 2026 vote.
Polls suggest the three parties are running close, with Plaid presenting itself as a “government-in-waiting” while Reform aims to break through with what leader Nigel Farage has promised will be “fresh thinking.”
Coalition
Mr ap Iorwerth was pressed on whether Plaid would consider a coalition deal with Labour to prevent Reform UK from entering government. He declined to rule it out but insisted Plaid’s aim was to lead a minority administration of its own.
“We certainly want to keep Reform out, I think, in the interest of Wales,” he told Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg. “We would be in a position now if the polls are anywhere near to reflecting what the vote would be to being able to form a minority government of our own. Remember there has never been a majority government in the history of devolution in Wales.”
He said Plaid would ask other parties to back its programme for government on key priorities including poverty, childcare and the economy. “What we’re doing is offering new leadership for Wales, a new way of doing things … under Plaid Cymru leadership that we haven’t had before.”
Labour, which has governed Wales since devolution began in 1999, is facing criticism for its handling of the steel crisis, while also battling the perception of fatigue after more than two decades in power.
Independence
The Plaid Cymru leader also said that the Welsh Parliament election will not equate to a vote on independence as the country is not ready for a referendum on its future.
However, addressing his party conference over the weekend, he told members a Plaid Cymru government would “kick-start” a debate on independence.
“In developing a prospectus for a new Wales, we’ll build on the excellent work of the Independent Commission on the Constitutional Future of Wales by establishing a standing commission,” he said.
The party leader has already ruled out a referendum in the first term of a Plaid government.
Speaking to the PA news agency, Mr ap Iorwerth said: “This isn’t an independence election next year.
“I don’t think we’re at the point where we have a referendum on independence.
“What I see, though, is Wales having come a long way during my lifetime, in recent years, from direct Westminster rule only a quarter of a century ago.
“More and more people are saying, yeah, tell us more about what independence could look like.
“Now, I don’t think we’re at that point yet, but I am excited, and I am curious, and I am eager to investigate with the people of Wales whether there’s a different way of doing things.
“What I see is an ongoing debate on how Wales can reach its potential.
“It’s not going to be me that makes the call, it’s me that offers leadership in having that debate.”
Disaffected voters
Reform UK, meanwhile, is targeting working-class and disaffected voters across south Wales, with Farage saying he intends to use “every devolved power” to support business and jobs.
The Reform leader claimed his team is working on a full policy platform, though he said it was “too early” to announce detailed pledges.
The Caerphilly by-election later this month is being seen as a marker for next May’s Senedd election. The vote was triggered by the the sudden death of Labour’s Hefin David in August.
The candidates in the by-election on 23 October are: Lindsay Whittle for Plaid Cymru; Llyr Powell for Reform; Richard Tunnicliffe for Labour; Gareth Potter for the Conservatives; Gareth Hughes for the Greens; and Anthony Cook for Gwlad. Steve Aicheler is running for the Liberal Democrats and Roger Quilliam is the candidate for UKIP.
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.


What new industries / jobs has Plaid brought to Wales?
Today on this website is details of new jobs in Central Swansea.
We’re seeing new longer trains from TfW made in Wales; Cardiff University and Swansea University expanding with government grants to enable growth on non-academic ventures.
Lampeters University being repurposed as a higher education institute, the list goes on and on.
If Plaid want to be taken seriously they need to compete with Labour for job creation and not purely criticise.
Plaid cannot easily bring industries or jobs to Wales, it is not in power. It runs a few councils sure, but it can’t do much there without the right policy in place from the Senedd, which is currently controlled by Labour.
The Senedd / UK government controls policies, but spend by organisations such as Universities is at their discretion.
Last week I was interviewed on Wales social value policy by a researcher from Cardiff University.
I have formally written to the University and copied Lee Waters on the poor use of University funding; specifically over the award of the retrofit project to a consultant from Holland https://www.arcadis.com/en-gb/news/europe/united-kingdom/2025/9/arcadis-appointed-to-lead-decarbonisation-of-cardiff-university-sites
They should have partnered with an organisation such as https://cat.org.uk/?gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=20913678138&gbraid=0AAAAADgkRkSFMqaT1adM68hgV33KEjA4K and then delivered similar projects to all Welsh Universities – this is basic procurement.
Quite… but not of this is in the purview of Plaid… last I checked Plaid does not run universities.
Blimey, have you ever met anyone from Cat? such a wasted opportunity . Agree it probably didn’t need to go to the Netherlands, but definetly not them!
That in really a stupid question 1 THEY ARE NOT IN POWER 2 ITS THE LONDON GOVERNMENT JOB TO GET JOBS FOR WALES Welsh governments do not have the financial clout in Wales we only get the crumbs hence no money for H S 2 not like Scotland and Northern Ireland that got a couple of BILLION £ each
Fundamentally disagree.
I worked in 2017 for Sellafield Limited and created thousands of jobs in Cumbria and lots for University of Manchester (campus in region) – UK government gave zero support.
Welsh organisations need to start working together to grow economy.
Very good points that you make.
Thanks. February this year I went to http://www.gcre.wales for the day and spent the whole day telling them how the consultants they were using were not performing. 2006 – 2012 I was Network Rails procurement lead for Signalling innovation projects. In 2023 i spent six months working for the UK government looking at how to better spend £60 billion public procurement spend. There is more UK government could do, but also other organisations such as Universities / Swansea Bay City Region etc need to lead the growth of well-paid roles. Andy Street persuaded HSBC to move its’ UK HQ to… Read more »
Er, it was shut under the Try gov. They are still a private enterprise. Not sure what Plaid could have done. They will never be in UK power.
Yes the UK gov should force a sale back to the UYK, a national strategic resource should never have been sold under Maggie.
It’s a triple whammy. First they failed to save primary steel. Second, they found no new industry to replace it. And third, there’s no sign of a massive Bilbao-style regeneration project. Nothing but a bit of cash to retrain for nonexistent jobs.
Point 1, a completely fair assessment, the economic conditions are not great for steel sellers in the UK. Point 2, that’s not true, the steel furnaces will be replaced with electric arc furnaces, thereby recycling waste steel into new products. Point 3, They don’t need a ‘regeneration’ project, this is not a ‘closure’ of an industry its a transition from one to another and finally, the workers have been given redundancy payment and extra support from Tata to retrain. As for non existent jobs, there are in fact many jobs out there, people may need to move to where the… Read more »
Point 2 was about new industrial jobs (i.e. not steel) to make up for the 2000+ lost steel jobs. Seasonal fruit picking isn’t the answer.
Point 3 is about transitioning and diversifying a local economy that was entirely dependent on steel which has just been decimated in size.
I suggest you visit Bilbao to see how it can be done.
Good point about “Construction, Trades, Logistics are all crying out for workers, as is hospitality and farm food pickers”. My Welsh father from Cymmer (my Welsh mother being from Bedwas) moved the family to London in search of work via a council house exchange with a Welsh family in London seeking to return to Wales. My father found work (he was a professional painter and decorator (having served a decent time as an apprentice) in bustling London – no problem. He did some of the gold leaf work on the clock on the clock tower of Cardiff Castle such was… Read more »
Was not Labour’s fault, it was the Tory’s fault. By the point Labour got into power it was basically too late to do anything about it. Also, unlike the other plant the owners had a plan for the future use of the site, electric arc furnaces, so while it’s a shut down it doesn’t mean the site is down and out. A loss of virgin steel to be sure, but we can import that cheaply.
Naturally I’d support opening a new virgin steel plant, but it would have to be economically viable to do so. (i.e. protectionist steel tariffs)
Unlike a blast furnace of virgin steel an electric arc furnace can be switched off when prices are low or slack demand and cannot make the high quality industry demands. Tata of course has both. In India. They also operate blast furnaces at IJmuiden in Netherlands to supply the EU markets but the profitability of an electric arc furnace depends on the electricity price. Britain has one of the highest prices for electricity in the world. Not sustainable.
Low carbon electricity is going to be gifted to the site at low cost to decarbonise manufacturing, as per terms of TCA and to avoid anti competition laws.
The bigger risk is potentially lack of recyclable steel in Europe in a few years time!
No it isn’t. A new interconnector into the site from the 400Kv transmission lines across south Wales with the view to drawing load from the 2,200Mw LNG Power Station at Pembroke. The idea that this electric arc furnace will be powered by solar panels or wind turbines is fantasy. Also, the scrap steel in Europe is more cost effective loaded onto otherwise empty bulk carriers on their return trip to India than shipped to Port Talbot, a wharf which needs annual dredge.
err…no, it won’t be using electricity from pembrokeshire and it won’t be using solar/wind.
The comments on this forum can be bonkers. So much misinformation