Support our Nation today - please donate here

News in brief: Simon Hart urged to condemn PM’s ‘deeply disrespectful coal mines remarks

06 Aug 2021 8 minute read
Simon Hart (left) by Chris McAndrew (CC BY 3.0).

Plaid Cymru’s Westminster leader, Liz Saville Roberts MP, has written to the Secretary of State for Wales, Simon Hart MP, urging him to condemn the Prime Minister’s “deeply disrespectful” remarks on Margaret Thatcher’s closure of coal mines.

On a visit to Scotland yesterday, the Prime Minister said that Margaret Thatcher gave “a big early start” to green energy by closing coal mines.

Ms Saville Roberts says that Thatcher’s closure of the pits “had nothing to do with climate change and everything to do with a ploy to destroy what she termed ‘the enemy within” – the miners and their communities’.

She also criticised the UK Government for continuing to “pick the pockets of Welsh miners, now pensioners, through the Mineworkers’ Pension Scheme”. Ms Saville Roberts says that a “real apology” from the Government would be to “reform the Government’s role [in the Scheme] and to improve members’ benefits.”


“Former Welsh mining communities – just like those in Scotland and the north of England – are still suffering the devastation wrought by Margaret Thatcher’s callous economic policies and obsession with destroying workers’ representation, Ms Saville Roberts’ wrote in her letter to Mr Hart.

“For the Prime Minister to use those communities as a joke punchline is deeply disrespectful, as is his fatuous attempt at rewriting history.

“Thatcher’s closure of the pits had nothing to do with climate change and everything to do with a ploy to destroy what she termed ‘the enemy within’ – the miners and their communities. Rather than reskilling workers for the industries of the future, Thatcher bulldozed whole communities in the name of right-wing economic ideology.”

“To make matters worse, the UK Government continues to pick the pockets of Welsh and UK miners, now pensioners, through the Mineworkers’ Pension Scheme. The UK Government has received approximately £4.4 billion from the scheme, with the expectation of a further £1.9 billion as well as 50 per cent of any future surplus in due course, even though the Government is yet to contribute a single penny into the scheme itself, she added.

“A real apology for the Prime Minister’s crass remarks would be to review the Government’s rejection of the Business, Energy and Industrial Select Committee to reform the Government’s role and for improved members’ benefits.

“As the UK Government’s representative in Wales, you must condemn Boris Johnson’s mocking remarks. A failure to do so will confirm that the Conservatives care nothing about the human consequences of the destruction they imposed on Wales in the past.

“If that is the case, we can only conclude that vulnerable communities seeking support to make the necessary shift away from fossil fuel employment today will be as dispensable to Boris Johnson as mining communities were to Margaret Thatcher.”

Photo by Mufid Majnun on Unsplash

Covid infections in Wales fall by over 30%

The number of people In Wales with Covid-19 has fallen by over 30%, according to the latest figures from the Office for National Statistics.

In the week ending 31 July, the ONS estimates 13,000 had the virus, down 30.9% from 18,800 the previous week.

Wales continues to have the lowest estimated percentage of the UK population infected at 0.43% for the most recent week surveyed, down from 0.62 for the week ending 24 July.

Northern Ireland was the only nation to record an increase in cases in the new study, with infections rising from 27,200 to 34,400, 1.87% of the population, while England recorded the second highest rate at 1.23%, recording 722,300 cases, down from   856,200 the previous week.

Scotland was estimated to have 43,000 Covid cases, down from 49,500 last week, for a rate of 0.82%.

Meanwhile today’s update from Public Health Wales has confirmed 803 new cases of coronavirus and no further deaths in the last day.

Cardiff (66) posted the highest number of new cases since Thursday’s report, followed by Flintshire (53) and Wrexham and Swansea both with 46.

The weekly case rate has fallen from 133.4 per 100,000 people to 133.2 since yesterday, and for the seven days up to 1 August, four of 22 local authorities have posted case numbers in double figures, Blaenau Gwent (64) Ceredigion (68) Anglesey (73) and Merthyr (80).

Cardiff has reported 441 new cases, the most in Wales, but the weekly case rate in Denbighshire remains the highest in the country at 335.4, down from 356.3 yesterday.

Health Minister Eluned Morgan. Picture by the Welsh Government.

Teenagers could be offered Covid jabs before schools and colleges reopen in September

Sixteen and 17-year-olds in Wales could be offered Covid jabs before they return to school following the end of the summer break.

Health Minister Eluned Morgan confirmed invitations could start going out within the next few days following a change in the guidance issued by the Joint Committee on Vaccine and Immunisation, which earlier this week expanded eligibility for the vaccine.

“We are hoping that we will be able to get this done, ideally, before they go back to their sixth forms, their colleges at the beginning of September,” the minister said.

In July the JCVI ruled out widening the vaccination programme to include younger teenagers, pointing out that up to the end of March this year, fewer than 30 children had died because of the virus in the UK.

It also described jabs as having minimal health benefits as coronavirus rarely causes severe disease in children without underlying health conditions.

“Until more safety data is available and has been evaluated, a precautionary approach is preferred,” it added in a statement issued at the time.

Kinmel Bay. Photo by Reading Tom, licensed under CC BY 2.0

Resort’s ‘ludicrous’ sea defences slammed

Jez Hemming, local democracy reporter

A councillor said it’s “ludicrous” a North Wales holiday destination has “such a poor promenade sea defence” and called new plans to be a “corporate risk” to the tourism industry.

Cllr Nigel Smith (Kinmel Bay) told a meeting of Conwy county council’s finance and resources scrutiny committee that some sections of sea defences in Towyn and Kinmel Bay were so narrow emergency vehicles couldn’t access the beach.

Cllr Smith claimed a woman recently injured her ankle on rock revetments and Rhyl lifeboat station had to send a crew to collect her and take her to Kinmel Bay to get access to medical help.

He also said putting rocks on the beach at Llandudno, to mitigate rising tides, had damaged the town’s tourism business.

Former cabinet member for economic development Cllr Goronwy Edwards rebuffed the claim, saying Llandudno and Towyn and Kinmel Bay had seen “more tourists than ever”.

Cllr Smith said: “Looking at my own area, Kinmel Bay and Towyn, we have the narrowest promenade in Conwy, if not the whole of Wales.

“It just seems ludicrous to me an area like Towyn and Kinmel Bay, which houses the most densely populated area in Western Europe for holiday accommodation, with 55,000 visitors during peak season, has such a poor promenade sea defence.

“Yet officers are not offering us an alternative, just dumping more rocks and stones on that beach, which has a detrimental effect to the economy of Conwy, because tourism is our biggest earner.

“I really feel there ought to be something on this risk register where when officers submit plans for poorly designed sea defences, not taking consideration of the (tourism) economy of the county – that should be classed as a risk in my mind.”

Cllr Greg Robbins , cabinet member for environment, said consultancy work was about to be commissioned on devising new sea defences for Towyn and Kinmel Bay.

He said: “As Cllr Nigel was aware they are going to look at the options for potentially widening the promenade, if possible. Bear in mind Welsh Government strategy is you don’t move into the sea, you hold the line or withdraw the line, you don’t advance the line. But this is something the consultants have been asked to look into once they’ve been commissioned into this work.”

Cllr Smith said he would like to see the risk of building sea defences which don’t “enhance” the area highlighted “more prominently” in the register.

He was advised to take up issue of their design with the authority’s environment, roads and facilities chief Geraint Edwards.

“We could be making the wrong decisions where people are not feeling safe,” added Cllr Smith. “And the flood defences may have an effect on the prosperity of our tourist economy.”

Cllr Goronwy Edwards said: “The tourist economy in Llandudno and Kinmel Bay are very buoyant and we’ve seen more tourists than ever.

“So to say it is a risk you’d need to quantify that – there’s no quantifying it’s actually a risk at all. It’s getting the balance right between sea defence and economic development and it certainly didn’t come up in my time as cabinet member for economic development the type of sea defences we have was a risk.”

Conwy county council’s corporate risk register includes “an event that should it occur, would impact (its) ability to successfully achieve (its) outcomes”.

Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Mab Meirion
Mab Meirion
2 years ago

Return to sender, address unknown…

Barry Pandy
Barry Pandy
2 years ago

He’ll show where his loyalties lie as always. No doubt Simon Fart will come up with some pathetic excuse for Bojo the Clown just like the poodle propagandists at Boris’s Broadcasting Conservatives. As always Bojo will be allowed to get away with it.

j humphrys
j humphrys
2 years ago

Would it be possible to take UK Gov. to court of human rights over the Mineworkers Pension Scheme?

Huw Davies
Huw Davies
2 years ago
Reply to  j humphrys

They’re probably banking on there not being enough former miners still alive to bring a class action. I wonder if Boris has made a joke about that too!

2 years ago

Viceroy of Wales defend the interests of Cymru? And a TORY Viceroy at that? And a TORY from the JOHNSON kleptocracy at that?
Don’t hold your breath

Huw Davies
Huw Davies
2 years ago

Typical Boris public schoolboy joke. One day he’ll tell a double amputee to ‘cheer up, think of all the weight you’ve lost’. Good to see he’s still doing his bit to save the union. Long may he continue.

Last edited 2 years ago by Huw Davies
Steve Duggan
Steve Duggan
2 years ago

Good luck with that request Liz, it might hurt his peerage prospects !

2 years ago

Viceroy Shart carrying a request from Wales to Bozo the Clown!?

Even if we’ve slipped into some bizarre parallel universe where such a thing is possible, Bozo will pay no heed.

Last edited 2 years ago by defaid
Ieuan Evans
Ieuan Evans
2 years ago

He won’t respond to Liz’s request. After all he’s from Wolverhampton and has zero affinity to Wales. A modern day John Redwood.

2 years ago

In 1984 the miners were striking to defend their livelihoods and their communities.
At the same time Bunter would have recently “gone up” to Oxford to spend his time shouting “Buller, Buller!”

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.