Support our Nation today - please donate here

Open letter calls for police boss to resign for ‘victim blaming’ Sarah Everard comments

04 Oct 2021 4 minute read
Picture by Tim Dennell (CC BY 2.0).

An open letter has called for a police boss to resign for “victim blaming” comments he made about the murder of Sarah Everard.

The letter, on behalf of Stand Up to Domestic Abuse, condemned the Conservative North Yorkshire Police Crime Commissioner Philip Allot after he suggested that women should be more streetwise about what they can be arrested for.

In his comments, which were widely criticised, he claimed Sarah Everard should never have submitted to arrest by the police officer to snatched her. The former police officer who kidnapped Ms Everard from a busy London street in March was handed a whole life sentence.

The signatories of the letter include Rachel Williams, who founded Stand Up to Domestic Abuse after being was shot and severely injured by her violent partner in 2011, Arfon Jones, the former North Wales Police and Crime Commissioner, and the actor Michael Sheen.

It was sent to the North Yorkshire Police, Fire and Crime Panel, which it urged to take action on the matter.

The letter says: “We write this open letter to you as professionals involved in representing and safeguarding women and girls who are or are likely to be subjected to male violence here in Wales and England.

“We were appalled to read of Mr Philip Allott’s sexist comments about Sarah Everard following the sentencing of Wayne Couzens for her murder.

“Mr Allott’s comments of ‘victim blaming’ were from a bygone age and wholly inappropriate language from an elected Police and Crime Commissioner tasked by the Home Office and the Ministry of Justice to lead and progress work and implement the Victim’s Code of Practise.

“Whilst Mr Allot did apologise, it was too little too late and immense damage had been done. In short, we believe that Mr Allott’s comments have brought the Office of Police and Crime Commissioner into disrepute and that he should resign.

“We therefore ask that North Yorkshire Police and Crime Panel take this letter as a formal complaint and we ask that you take the appropriate action. This letter has been shared with the Independent Office of Police Conduct.”


Allott was speaking on BBC Radio York when he said “women should be aware this was not an indictable offence – one considered serious enough to warrant a prison sentence or crown court hearing.

“So, women, first of all, need to be streetwise about when they can be arrested and when they can’t be arrested. She should never have been arrested and submitted to that,” he said.

“Perhaps women need to consider in terms of the legal process, to just learn a bit about that legal process”.

After the furious outcry on social media, he tweeted: “I would like to wholeheartedly apologise for my comments on BBC radio York earlier today, which I realise have been insensitive and wish to retract them in full.”

The other signatories of the letter are:

  • Harriet Wistrich – Founder of Centre of Womens Justice, Solicitor, Winner of the Liberty Human Rights Lawyer of the Year award 2014, Legal Aid Lawyer of the year 2018 and Law Society Gazette personality of the year 2019. Harriet has acted in many high-profile cases around violence against women including on behalf of women who challenged the police and parole board in the John
    Worboys case.
  • Michael Sheen – Actor and Patron of SUTDA
  • Prof Jane Monckton Smith – Professor of Public Protection at Gloucestershire University. Homicide
  • David Challen – Domestic Abuse Campaigner, Ambassador for Prison Advice
  • France Beecher – CEO of Llamau
  • Julie Bindel – Author, Journalist, Broadcaster and Researcher
  • Nicola Sharp-Jeffs – Founder & CEO of SEA (Surviving Economic Abuse)
  • Michelle Whelan – CEO CalanDVS
  • Shona Priddey – Criminologist and Court Magistrate
  • Mark Hegarty – Founder of WCID (What Can I Do?)
  • Clare Walker – Founder of Clare Walker Consulting LTD (Domestic Abuse Consultant)
  • Maria Gallagher – Director of Feminist Law Society
  • Cathy Press – Founder & CEO of Escape the Trap, Awareness Matters, Who’s in Charge?

Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Dim problem
Dim problem
2 years ago

The signatories of the letter include Rachel Williams, who founded Stand Up to Domestic Abuse after being was shot and severely injured by her violent partner in 2011, Arfon Jones, the former North Wales Police and Crime Commissioner, and the actor Michael Sheen.”

I think that sentence needs a bit of sub-editing… I did a double take!

Gill Jones
Gill Jones
2 years ago
Reply to  Dim problem

You have a big problem and are certainly dim (the english version)

2 years ago

The open letter is off-target.

Mr Allnot’s retracted comments are an admission that women cannot trust his officers. If that’s what he believes, he should stand by what he said (and apologise instead for the crass way in which he said it). It’s his retraction that should be the first grounds for resignation because it’s shifty.

2 years ago

Terrible things happen in other countries – the Welsh signatories of this letter are using their time and their influence to bolster a system that most readers on this site oppose. Whether one agrees or disagrees with the sentiment, those who signed are tacitly supporting the institutions of the UK by seeking reform.

It won’t be draconian measures that keep us in this broken Union, but an appeal to our empathy. The Guardian are more of a threat to our freedom than the Army. Dihunwch, Cymru Fach.

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.