Support our Nation today - please donate here
News

Petition launched opposing windfarm of ‘national significance’

13 Aug 2024 3 minute read
Campaigner Matt Davies on Mynydd Maen, above Cwmbran with the high rise Tower block in the distance, at the proposed location for one of the Mynydd Maen

Twm Owen Local Democracy Reporter

A petition opposed to a potential wind farm on a Gwent mountain has been signed more than 2,300 times. 

Campaigner Matt Davies, of Cwmbran, began collecting signatures online after he learned late last year of the proposal for up to 13 wind turbines on Mynydd Maen which is to the north west of the town and east of Newbridge and Crumlin. 

Mr Davies, who lives in Thornhill, has also highlighted his concerns about the impact of a separate plan for up to four turbines, west of the mountain and east of Newbridge and south of Hafodyrynys, in Caerphilly borough, and the Cil-Lonydd solar farm to the south of the village and east of Pantside which could use the same grid connection as the planned Mynydd Maen wind farm.

National significance

All three proposals are considered developments of national significance, due to the amount of energy they could generate, and as such an independent planning inspector on behalf of national planning body Planning and Environment Decisions Wales (PEDW) will have to make a recommendation to the Welsh Government on whether to approve or reject the plans. 

Borough councils will be expected to compile impact reports setting out how the proposals could affect their areas, but councillors will only get to give their opinions. 

Mr Davies said he would like Torfaen and Caerphilly borough councils to come out in opposition to the current proposals. 

“I would like to see them backing the residents,” said Mr Davies: “Over 2,300 people have signed the petition and the more people who find out, the more want to sign. It would be nice to see the leaders get behind it and say they don’t want it up there.” 

Proposals

The four turbines proposed by Pennant Walters, for the Trecelyn wind farm, within Caerphilly borough would measure up to 145 metres to the tips of their blades and the 13 planned by RES at Mynydd Maen, with the land split between Caerphilly and Torfaen, could be 149.9m tall. 

“That is twice the height of The Tower flats in Cwmbran,” said Mr Davies who has also also highlighted concern at the impact of construction traffic on narrow roads in the area as well as “industrialisation” of the mountain and impact on peatlands. 

He also claimed wind farms would hit house prices in the area and is sceptical of the power generation capabilities and believes off shore wind is a more suitable form or renewable energy generation. 

Mr Davies is collecting signatures on his Stop Mynydd-Maen Wind Farm petition on the Change.org website where he has also posted links to websites for each development, created by the developers, that sets out detailed technical information about their proposals and mitigation measures. 

Maps showing the locations are also available.

A spokeswoman for RES said it is currently waiting for formal confirmation from PEDW it has validated its planning application for the Mynydd Maen windfarm and once it has received confirmation there will be a five week consultation period publicised by PEDW. 


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

7 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Elaine
Elaine
4 months ago

I saw an interview with Jo Stevens just after the GE when she talked about Welsh government having responsibility for most planning here but she also pointed out that an exemption to the Wales Act was for projects of national importance. These may be overridden by the SoS for Energy in London ie Miliband.
I presume she’s correct so there could be trouble ahead for a handful of projects.

Jonathan Dean
Jonathan Dean
4 months ago

Well done! Wales can generate more than enough electricity from offshore wind

Adrian
Adrian
4 months ago
Reply to  Jonathan Dean

It’s intermittent. and you can’t store it Jonathan. What do you propose to do when the wind doesn’t blow?

Charles Coombes
Charles Coombes
4 months ago
Reply to  Adrian

It can be stored in batteries or
It can be sold cheaply when there’s too much.
No problem.

Adrian
Adrian
4 months ago

…and so it begins! Net Zero has always been a scientifically-baseless act of economic suicide, Once ideology collides with reality though, it generally starts falling apart. The eco-loons all love wind turbines…as long as they’re in someone else’s back yard. Once the actual cost of this idiocy starts to become clear people will wake up.

Last edited 4 months ago by Adrian
Welsh Patriot
Welsh Patriot
4 months ago

We need renewable energy in Wales, too many NIMBY’S

Charles Coombes
Charles Coombes
4 months ago

Hope all the 2300 will turn their lights out, stop charging their phones and watching television.!

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.