Plaid Cymru MS leaves cross-party group in culture wars row

Martin Shipton
A Plaid Cymru MS has withdrawn from a newly established cross-party Senedd group on women’s and girls’ rights days after joining it.
The withdrawal of Safa Elhassan, who represents Gŵyr Abertawe, appears to stem from the group’s acceptance of the Supreme Court’s ruling that sex in equality legislation means biological sex only. The group will now have representatives from just three of the four main parties: Reform UK, Labour and the Conservatives.
When the group was launched, its chair, Tory MS Natasha Asghar, said: “The creation of this group marks an important milestone as it is the Senedd’s first ever cross-party group looking solely at the rights of women and girls in Wales.
“I am clear that I do not want this group to be a talking shop. I want it to be a vital platform where politicians, experts and others can come together to better understand what the law says about women’s and girls’ rights, what it means in practice, and how it should be reflected in policy and Welsh public bodies.
“Given the Supreme Court’s recent ruling that sex is defined as biological sex only, I hope the group will play a key role in ensuring public bodies are adhering to the law, particularly when it comes to single-sex spaces.”
At the group’s inaugural meeting, members agreed on topics to cover, including gender distress, barriers facing women and girls in sport, lesbian rights and the impact of pornography on young people.
But when the list of MSs involved in the group was published, Ms Elhassan’s name was missing.
We asked Plaid Cymru for an explanation and were sent a statement in which Ms Elhassan was quoted as saying: “There are two cross-party groups in the Senedd relating to women and women’s rights. I inadvertently attended one that did not align with my values or those of my party.
“Once I became aware of the issue, I took immediate steps to correct the mistake by resigning my membership of the Women and Girls’ Rights CPG and joining the CPG for Women, supported by Women’s Equality Network Wales.”
We asked Plaid Cymru to explain how the Women’s and Girls’ Rights CPG did not align with Ms Elhassan’s values or those of the party.
A Plaid spokesperson said: “Plaid Cymru is a party committed to protecting the rights of LGBTQ+ people in Wales, just as we are committed to equality for women and girls. These are not mutually exclusive. We will always stand up for equality and dignity for everyone in our communities.”
A political source said: “My understanding is that Safa Elhassan was bullied by Plaid Cymru male staff members into withdrawing from the group and was quite upset about how the matter was handled.”
Statement of opinion
We also asked why Ms Elhassan’s husband, Gwyn Williams, had withdrawn his support for a Senedd Statement of Opinion on women’s right to single-sex spaces.
Plaid Cymru sent us a statement from Dr Williams that said: “I signed this Statement of Opinion in error in June and, once the mistake was brought to my attention, I asked for my name to be removed.
“The statement did not reflect my or the party’s views and so I do not support its contents. I regret the administrative error but consider the matter closed.”
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.


Oh come off it Plaid. It’s so obvious what’s happened here that it’s almost laughable. Plus the lack of any sense regarding the optics of this is just juvenile. They would have been far better served if they had kept an MS on this group. The fact they haven’t shows they have no clue. Amateurish of them at best. The party clearly doesn’t want to say out loud that they disagree with women’s legal rights in single sex spaces and services because it’s the law, and because they would expose themselves as dangerous ideologues, but they are shutting down any… Read more »
Oh god, this is pathetic. Weren’t they just saying they accept the law? If so, why is this silly stunt necessary? Trying to make women’s rights all about different groups of people is misogyny. Women’s rights should of course centre women. Plaid need to respect the 51% of the population they are currently thumbing their nose at.
Got to wonder at the competence of 2 people in a position of power who seem prone to such fundamental administrative mistakes! One joined the wrong meeting and one signed a statement in error. It’s either incompetence or deceit or maybe both . . .
It looks as if the Labour, Reform and Conservative bots are out in force tonight. It is a pity they were not as passionate about repairing all the damage done to Wales through their support for three parties that have ravaged our country. And whether or not you agree with trans rights, or with this Plaid Cymru MS, Safa Elhassan, walking away from that group on principle, demonising her—and those discriminated against on the margins of society—says a great deal about you, not her. Oh yes, and do not forget the calamity of 27 years of stagnant Welsh Labour rule… Read more »
Strange to omit any mention of what this group is focussed on above all else – the exclusion of innocent trans women. Even the comments here show that’s all this group is about, when there’s plenty of genuine things to worry about such as the creeping attacks on reproductive rights, access to IVF and HRT and the huge increase in violent misogyny from cis men.
Open your eyes, the trans movement is all about violent misogyny. No man who enters a woman only space is innocent, he is an entitled invader.
Weird, I get far less of a violent vibe off my trans friends than the likes of you.
Shows how much you know.
Or who, which is to say trans people. You’ve never had a conversation with a trans person except to yell at us for being dangerous abusers.
Nice sweeping generalisation there. Way to falsely state that trans people only ever transition to inflict violence against women. Tell me something though – was the cop who raped and murdered Sarah Everard a cis man or a trans woman?
That is irrelevant whataboutery. Look at the crime statistics.
Which ones? Please show me the crime stats which show trans people are more likely to be predators than anyone else. The same rhetoric was weaponised against gay and bi people. Do you believe everyone within the LGBTQ+ is a potential sex offender?
So there’s already a womens’ CPG run by the wonderful WEN.
This new group is not for the rights of women and girls, it’s for the attempted eradication of trans people.
You can see that there was not oe topic o tat agenda that was not about attacking trans people and trying to frame EHRC “guidance” as “law”. Which it is not.
If your entire existence is predicated on the removal of other people’s rights, then you should be made to rename your org to reflect your true purpose.
The EHRC guidance is guidance ON the law TM. The Equality Act 2010 and the Workplace Regs 1992 are the law and the Supreme Court judgment clarified the law with regard to the Equality Act. Do keep up. “If your entire existence is predicated on the removal of other people’s rights” – well you’ve pretty much said it all there. No trans rights have been removed or are being sought to be removed. Whereas women’s legal rights were removed by men assuming an entitlement into women’s spaces and services that they never had. This CPG is ensuring the legal rights… Read more »
I’ve said it before but there’s no way you’ve read the EHRC Code if you’re claiming it’s clear. It won’t even categorically say you have to provide single-sex toilets.
The EHRC “guidance” is a massive overreach of the law which says NONE of the sweeping segretgationist nonsense included by the ideologically captured EHRC.
Even the “clarification” itself us suspect as the entire legal profession did a collective “WTF?” at the Justice Hodge’s pronouncement, since it is in direct contradiction to all the evidence presented
By the ‘entire legal profession’, you mean the Good Law Project TM who manage to lose the vast majority of cases they get involved in. Embarrassing! The rest of the legal profession agree. Once again, the EHRC Code cannot be a ‘massive overreach of the law’ – as it’s not the law, it’s guidance on the law for duty bearers. No matter how much you repeat this mistake, it remains a mistake. And you shot yourself in the foot with your comment “If your entire existence is predicated on the removal of other people’s rights” as that is precisely what… Read more »
WEN is a women’s right group
WRN is an anti trans network
If women’s rights are anti trans then logically trans rights are anti women … right???
You’d need to be using a specific type of ‘equals’ for that sort of logic to follow.
I know this might be hard for you to believe but it’s not a zero sum issue. Cis women won’t lose out from trans women being treated with dignity and respect. This is not an either/or scenario.
We’ve already missed out by being reduced to a subcategory ‘cis’.
Women = Adult Female Human, ‘cis’ is surplus to requirement, there’s only one category of women.
Im not cis Im just a woman no need for a prefix. Transwomen are men however they identify and whatever they wear.
Like the vast majority, I simply don’t care about the angst of single issue fanatics. But if Plaid persist with such ridiculous stunts they will pay a heavy price at the next election.