Support our Nation today - please donate here

Police forces under investigation for response to missing car crash victims

07 Mar 2023 5 minute read
People attend a vigil in the St Mellons area of Cardiff, in memory of Eve Smith, 21, Darcy Ross, 21, and Rafel Jeanne, 24, who died in a road traffic accident, while Sophie Russon, 20, and Shane Loughlin, 32, survived but remain in a critical condition. Picture Ben Birchall PA Images

The Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) has launched an investigation into two police forces for their search response to missing victims of a deadly car crash in Cardiff amid criticism they did not take matters seriously.

Eve Smith and Darcy Ross, both 21, and Rafel Jeanne, 24, died in the collision, while Sophie Russon, 20, and Shane Loughlin, 32, are in a critical condition, police said.

All five were in a Volkswagen Tiguan which left the A48(M) in Cardiff and hit trees in the St Mellons area of the city.

David Ford, IOPC director, said: “After careful assessment of referrals from Gwent police and South Wales police, we have decided to independently investigate how police responded to the missing person reports.

“We will be examining what information police had, the grading given to any risk assessments and the steps taken by police to locate the missing people prior to the Volkswagen Tiguan being found just after midnight on Monday.

“We will also consider what communication took place between the two forces and whether police action was appropriate and followed relevant policy and procedures.”

A vigil was underway at the crash site on Tuesday evening.

The group had been to a social club in Maesglas, Newport, on Friday night and are thought to have then travelled 40 miles to the Trecco Bay area of Porthcawl.

Police have confirmed they were last seen at about 2am on Saturday in Pentwyn, Cardiff.

Officers believe the car was involved in a collision and left the A48(M) some time later, but further investigations are needed to establish an exact time.

After failing to go home, the five were reported missing by their families.

The first call was made to police at 7.34pm on Saturday, while further reports were made until 5.37pm on Sunday.

Hundreds of people took part in searches but Gwent Police did not issue a public appeal for help until 11pm on Sunday.


In a joint statement, Gwent and South Wales Police said a police helicopter was asked to search an area of Cardiff at 11.50pm on Sunday, which the forces said led to the vehicle being found 25 minutes later.

But members of the friends’ search party, Matthew Pace, 45, and his son Lewis, 26, told Sky News they found the car shortly before officers arrived after seeing tyre marks leading off the road and into a wooded area.

Tamzin Samuels, 20, a friend of the young women and who helped in the search effort, told the PA news agency: “I do think the police could have done a lot more in putting the helicopters out earlier.

“They only posted the appeal an hour before the girls were found. We found them before the police found them – we rang the police.”

Two women who were friends of the Loughlin family questioned the police response.

They said: “The police were terrible. I don’t think they took it seriously.”

They added: “The families said it was out of character for them to go missing and the police should have listened to them.

“Shane’s mum was up all weekend worried sick.

“The boys from Cardiff, all their friends were driving around looking for them. It was those people looking who found them, not the police.”

Tributes to those who died have been paid on social media.

A friend of Mr Loughlin posted: “I’m so proud of us all pulling together out there searching for our dear friends last night.

“It’s heart breaking what’s happened to Rafel Jeanne and those two girls. My body is still shaking and I can’t stop being sick (at) the thought of them all there all of that time.”

Car crash

Ms Smith’s death comes eight years after her sister Xana Doyle, 19, was killed in a car crash. The driver, who was twice the drink-drive limit, was prosecuted and Ms Smith took part in a Sky TV documentary about the incident and campaigned for tougher sentences.

Another sister paid tribute to her in a Facebook post.

“I know you’re safe up with there with our beautiful sister Xana but I was never ready to let you go, my body is aching without you,” she said.

In a statement, Ms Smith’s family asked for their privacy to be respected.

They added: “We want to allow Gwent Police and South Wales Police the time and space to investigate the matter in a thorough and professional way and to enable the Independent Office for Police Conduct thereafter to come to their own conclusions.”

Gwent Police’s Assistant Chief Constable Mark Hoborough and South Wales Police’s Assistant Chief Constable Jason Davies said their thoughts are with victims’ families.

Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
1 Comment
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Ivor Schilling
Ivor Schilling
1 year ago

Had the arrived earlier, they may have found some of the three still alive. That is the point,

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.