Public uproar at plans to concrete over family farm to build business park
Alex Seabrook, local democracy reporter
Campaigners are fighting to save a family farm east of Cardiff Airport from turning into a 45-acre business park.
The Jenkins family were asked to leave their farm by the end of July next year as the landowners want to build an industrial estate there.
Since 1935, four generations of the family have worked at Model Farm, on Port Road in the Vale of Glamorgan.
Legal and General, a financial services firm which owns the land, received planning permission last month to build a business park on the farm.
A campaign group set up to save Model Farm is quickly gaining thousands of supporters, raising money for legal fees to appeal the decision, and planning a protest by the Senedd.
Politicians have slammed Vale of Glamorgan council for granting planning permission, which in the same month declared a ‘nature emergency’ and pledged to protect the environment.
Legal and General said the business park would create more than 3,000 jobs and bring in £94 million of wages each year. The council said it would help support the local economy.
Kelly Ball lives and works at Model Farm with her husband Rhys Jenkins and their two daughters, aged one and three years old, and Rhys’s father Gethin. She said the family is still in shock and is unsure where they will move to next year.
She said: “We’ve been given 12 months, until July 31 next year. They handed our notice to use on July 31 just gone, with a letter delivered by an enforcement officer. We have had no contact with Legal and General whatsoever. We thought they would at least have the decency to sit us down and talk to us about it. It’s shocking how they’re treating us.
“We haven’t spoken about [where we’ll go]. We didn’t think it was going to go ahead. We didn’t think they would pursue the plans with Covid, and with the climate emergency the Vale council has declared, we didn’t think they would let this go ahead.
“Rhys will try to carry on the farm. Maybe something might come up between now and in 12 months time. But at the minute it’s all up in the air. As a family we’re just devastated.”
The family rear beef cattle and grow cereal crops and wildflowers, selling wildflower seeds across Wales. Model Farm lies north of Porthkerry Country Park. As part of the plans, Legal and General will give about 49 hectares of land towards extending the country park.
But despite the extension, local campaigners are claiming the business park will have a negative impact on the local environment, harming biodiversity and increasing congestion.
Vale Communities Unite, a community group set up to save Model Farm, has launched a fundraiser for legal fees, and is planning to protest outside the Welsh Parliament at 11am on Saturday, 21 August.
Gail Elizabeth, one of the campaigners, said: “I didn’t think it would get this far. When permission was granted I was horrified. There’s huge opposition from locals, and over 1,000 residents opposed it.
“The farmers have supported us over a number of years in various ways. They’re huge in the community and have been for years. The main road out of Rhoose, Porthkerry Road, has flooded on a number of occasions, so we were trapped. And the farmer pumped out the water for us and cleared the road.”
Maxine Levett, another campaigner, said: “We’re not opposed to development or building or jobs for locals, but we feel there are more appropriate sites in the Vale of Glamorgan within a couple of miles that could have been used. We have got huge areas of brownfield sites in the area that could have been used.
“There’s a huge range of biodiversity on that site. The council is rewilding in other places like Porthkerry Country Park, so why concrete over just above the park? It just goes against all their aims.
“When you drive home you have a beautiful view of the sea, the woodland and the fields, and you see all the birds, and the view of the viaduct. That view is going to be obliterated. This is being enforced upon us and we feel very angry about that.
“The community were in uproar after the decision was made. We were upset by how our comments had been disregarded. What’s the point of a public consultation and having a planning meeting if all your comments are going to be dismissed? The planning system needs to have a rethink.”
They both highlighted potential issues with traffic congestion the business park could cause. They claimed traffic surveys used in the planning application relied on future improvements to public transport, an estimated increase in people working from home and fewer commuting, and added how the lack of a proposed M4 link road would exacerbate problems.
This summer both the Senedd and Vale of Glamorgan council declared a ‘nature emergency’, pledging to protect biodiversity and prevent the loss of ecological habitats. In 2019 they also both declared a ‘climate emergency’, pledging to tackle carbon emissions and the climate crisis. These declarations have now been questioned, due to the Model Farm decision.
Janet Finch Saunders MS, Welsh Conservative climate change spokeswoman, said: “Just this week we saw the IPCC report saying it’s ‘code red for humanity’ — yet Welsh Labour don’t seem to have got the message.
“The Labour council’s decision is disastrous for the environment, will mean more congestion and greater pollution, and goes against everything their colleagues say about climate change in Cardiff Bay.”
Councillor Ian Johnson, Plaid Cymru group leader on the Vale council, said: “I cannot see how this development can sit alongside the climate emergency and nature emergency declared by the Senedd and Vale of Glamorgan council.
“We need an urgent statement from the Welsh Government about how the climate emergency and nature emergency affect planning regulations and guidance, and whether or not they support these plans for development at Model Farm.”
The Vale council’s planning committee approved planning permission on July 14. Nine Independent and Labour councillors voted in favour, while eight Plaid and Tory councillors voted against it. Labour argued the business park would create jobs in the local area. Legal and General have said an unnamed ‘high-profile employer’ would run the business park.
The council defended its decision by saying the land has been included in the local development plan since 2011, while Legal and General said the plans would create local jobs, bring in millions in new wages, and would give some land to Porthkerry Country Park.
A Vale of Glamorgan council spokesperson said: “This planning application was approved by the council’s planning committee last month following full consideration of all relevant factors, including those relating to its environmental impact. A report explaining exactly how the decision was reached can be found on the council’s website.
“This addresses in detail concerns relating to the climate emergency, local objections and support. It also notes that recently adopted Welsh Government policy supports the principle of this development given its strategic location, with connections to Wales’ only airport.
“Cardiff Airport is an essential part of Wales’ transport infrastructure. As an international gateway, it connects Wales to the rest of the world and helps drive the country’s economy. The wider Cardiff Airport and Bro St Athan Enterprise Zone also offer opportunities for investment, both within its parameters and surrounding areas of the Vale.
“This site has long been identified as a location for large-scale employment. It was first designated for this purpose in the council’s 2011 local development plan (LDP), a document that was subsequently adopted by the then Conservative-led council in 2017. That followed an examination in public led by a Welsh Government-appointed Planning Inspector.
“The LDP has been monitored on an annual basis since its adoption, with a report submitted to the Welsh Government every October. It is a legal requirement that all planning decisions are taken in accordance with the LDP unless material considerations indicate otherwise.”
A spokesperson from Legal and General said: “Forming part of the council’s local development plan since 2017, this important project has a strategic role to play in delivering wider economic, social and environmental benefits, including the capacity to accommodate over 3,000 jobs and supporting £94 million in wages each year.
“An environmental assessment underpins the plans for the site and the management and enhancement of natural habitats and wildlife are a key priority. In addition, over half the site — equivalent to circa 67 football pitches — will be handed over to Porthkerry Country Park, extending leisure and recreation facilities.
“Consideration of development opportunities of other alternative sites would have been extensively consulted on as part of the council’s local plan process. We sympathise with the tenant, Mr Jenkins, and will continue to communicate with him as part of the next steps in the process of enabling the delivery of this site and its wider community benefits.”
The campaigners vowed to continue fighting the decision to grant planning permission.
Ms Levett, the Vale Communities Unite campaigner, said: “We’re going to fight this decision all the way. We’re not nimbys and it’s not just about us. You’re saying don’t build on green land and here you are still building on green land.
“It’s been like a wave across the Vale of Glamorgan and Wales, and we’re saying enough is enough. They have to put a stop to it. They have to put their foot down.”
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.
Land reform more urgent than ever. Nationalise all land and grant farmers custody of land. Community lands to follow. No compensation!
Sick of the moneybags? Support the farming community!
Next big demo should feature this slogan.
L&G bought several sites adjacent to airports 20 years ago. They developed them all and this is the last. The tenants have known for decades so their outrage is a little manufactured. They would have been on short-term leases and probably far lower than commercial rents for that reason.
It is a very small farm to support a family and if they do get L&G to allow them to stay they may find the rent somewhat more than they are used to. We don’t have sufficient information to judge this case.
Manufactured outrage. Well said. This is a standard tactic in VoG. As a county it has always held itself above its neighbours. Rural villages devoid of anyone who was born there, with Bentleys and Porsches on every drive. Acres of fields tended by hired gardeners. High streets that practically have a dress code. People raging that “putting an industrial there will ruin the view on my drive home” is TYPICAL VoG. I cannot speak as to the actual facts of this case, but the Official motto of the Vale of Glamorgan is “Not in MY rear cottage garden (we don’t… Read more »
The statement by the Tory MS is incorrect, it is not a “Labour ” council, in fact the Tory party has the most councilors, but there is no overall control, as it has been since 2012.And the Senedd recently refused funding for road building to access Cardiff airport, due to environmental concerns.
Tories not telling the truth? Shurely shome mishtake!
Whatever the merits or otherwise of erasing a working farm and building a modern business park on its site, questions need to be asked about the viability of a business park on that location. Previous “major” developments in the Vale have underperformed. It appears to be some politician’s wet dream ( or maybe a developer) that never quite makes it in reality. Also the imbalance between different policies suggests that a “silo” mentality still exists. One unit pursues a green environmentalist outcome while its colleagues in the adjacent silo is seeking more growth from as yet unspecified sources. Capital down… Read more »