Support our Nation today - please donate here
News

Residents criticise ‘ugly’ metro electrification works

05 Feb 2025 3 minute read
Residents on Windemere Avenue, Cardiff said they were unhappy with electrification works behind their homes.

Ted Peskett, local democracy reporter

Residents, whose homes back onto a railway track, are unhappy with the appearance of recent work done by Transport for Wales (TFW).

TFW is currently carrying out work to electrify a number of lines that connect Cardiff with the Valleys.

Residents in Cyncoed, Cardiff, have complained about sight of large metal structures, and are worried it may have affected house prices.

Visual impact

The work involved the installation of metal gantries and wires along sections of railway track across the city, part of TFW’s South Wales Metro project.

A number of residents living on Windemere Avenue, in Cyncoed, said they were notified by TFW about electrification works, but they weren’t aware of the visual impact it would have.

One resident on Windemere Avenue who did not want to be named said: “We weren’t expecting the impact it would have on the view at the back of the garden and before all we could see were trees and occasionally bits of the Allensbank Graveyard, but that was in the winter.”

“We think it might have affected the house prices.”

Referencing one of a number of properties on the street that have been put up for sale over the past year, the resident added that they “couldn’t understand” why it had seemingly dropped in price.

“It’s great to have electrification, but obviously it affects our homes. There was no advance warning of what it would look like. It’s pretty ugly.”

Affected houses

Another resident, who did not want to be named, said the electrification works had “certainly affected houses around here”.

They added: “We let the hedge grow thinking that it would block it out.”

“We grew the hedge to be higher than the fencing and then the next thing [we knew] all of the wiring was put in.”

TFW carried out testing of electrification overhead power lines in Cardiff on February 1 and 2.

The TfW website states that its delivery partners for the Metro do not need planning permission to carry out upgrades to the railway line.

Unsafe vegetation

As part of the wider Metro scheme, TFW’s plan is to ultimately electrify 170km of track and will include lines to Aberdare, Coryton, Merthyr Tydfil, Rhymney and Treherbert.

A TFW spokesperson said: “As part of the transformational South Wales Metro project we will be electrifying 170km of track to allow us to operate our brand-new electric trains.”

“This involves the installation of Overhead Line Equipment (OLE) in accordance with industry guidelines to ensure the equipment, which carries 25,000 volts, is a safe height and distance from buildings and objects.”

The spokesperson said: “We will not be planting trees for the purposes of screening OLE, any areas identified as suitable for planting will be based on health and safety risks, maintenance, and ecology as per our organisational requirements and commitments.”

“Where overgrown trees have been removed for safety reasons or for the installation of infrastructure, it is not appropriate to replant trees in these same areas as this work is essential to ensure the safe running of the railway.”

“Vegetation near the railway can be a hazard and a tree falling across the track could result in a severe accident.”

They added: “We’ll also be undertaking routine management of unsafe vegetation – such as removing dead, dying or diseased trees and cutting back vegetation which is too close to the line.”


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

15 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Gareth W
Gareth W
12 days ago

“We think it might have affected the house prices.”

Ha! Has a more middle-class line ever been uttered, since a lady in Waitrose was heard to ask her husband, “Darling, do we need quinoa for both the houses?”

Electrification will make the trains run more quietly, so it might actually add value.

simhedges
simhedges
11 days ago
Reply to  Gareth W

Cheaper housing? Sounds great!

Rob
Rob
12 days ago

Some people just whine about anything

Nigel
Nigel
12 days ago

Some will prefer the quiet electric trains over the noisy diesels. Especially with a turn up and go service pattern.

Ed Thomas
Ed Thomas
12 days ago

Bless. It’s almost as if having a train line behind them was a positive thing in the first place.

Erik@
Erik@
12 days ago

Cardiff – Feel the potential ‘diff.
As for the most middle-class phrase, I thought “Who’ s going to serve us in Pret” was a blinder.

John Ellis
John Ellis
12 days ago

If you buy a house adjacent to a railway line, by implication you also buy into what the rail service providers might at some future point opt to do. No point in stridently whingeing after the event.

Lyn Thomas
Lyn Thomas
12 days ago

I remember when the West Midlands Metro was built people whose gardens backed on to it got, on average, £1 million per mile in compensation. However having a frequent reliable and fast service between Birmingham and Wolverhampton – that cut journey times (compared to a car) by 2/3 meant that house prices actually increased as a result. I think people near a metro line will find that the proximity to fast reliable turn up and go services – running quietly as electric trains will, might actually enhance their house prices.

Tom
Tom
12 days ago

These are probably the same people that think bulldozing half a city for a motorway would be mint, these idiots shouldn’t be taken seriously

Karen Lewis
Karen Lewis
12 days ago

For this green transport they massacred so many trees many extremely old. They have dug out large areas along the route and have covered the routein large steel structures. They have put lifts on the stations, which will often be broken as public lifts always are whereas, if they had left the stations one sided the disabled would be better catered for.

Siadwel
Siadwel
11 days ago
Reply to  Karen Lewis

Karen! Says it all, doesn’t it!!🤣

Karl
Karl
12 days ago

As someone who fit a while lived next to tube lines in London , tge quieter train will make up for the look. But the look is extreme compared to what you see in Spsin on their high speed lines. Extra thick construction in place here and grey that somehow sticks out. House price bit is funny. I bought my house to live in, it’s value us meaningless

Garycymru
Garycymru
12 days ago

These must be the same awful types that choose to move near a cultural centre like womanby Street, then complain about the noise.
It’s a train line, get over it.

McSaes
McSaes
11 days ago

It’s Lakeside, not Cyncoed and people I know who live in Windermere Drive tell me reporters knocked on their door, asking loaded questions and putting words in their mouths.

Matthew
Matthew
11 days ago

How odd that similar installations have been put in place throughout the South Wales Valleys and Cardiff but only the residents of one of the most affluent areas of Cardiff have kicked up a stink about it.

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.