Support our Nation today - please donate here
News

Speaker warns that abuse and threats are undermining democracy

02 Jun 2025 4 minute read
Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle Photo House of Commons/UK Parliament//PA Wire

The scale of abuse, threats and intimidation facing MPs is undermining the health of democracy, a cross-party inquiry has found.

A survey by the Speaker’s Conference revealed about half of MPs said threatening behaviour had caused anxiety or depression (49%), with a similar share feeling unsafe as a result (52%).

The inquiry concluded that electoral law is “not fit for purpose” in relation to tackling abuse of political candidates in elections and called for a Government review to assess security and electoral integrity.

This phase of the Conference was established in 2024 to help ensure that elections to Parliament are conducted freely and fairly, without threats or violence.

It also seeks to enable candidates to campaign safely and support elected representatives to do their job securely.

Privilege

Commenting on the findings, Sir Lindsay Hoyle, Commons Speaker and chairman of the Speaker’s Conference, said: “Participating in free and fair democratic processes – as a candidate or a Member of Parliament – is a privilege, and we expect that to come with robust political discourse and debate.

“But abuse, threats and intimidation should never be part of this job. It threatens the health of our democracy, and forces people to choose between the public good and their own safety and wellbeing.

“I am grateful to members, their staff and the witnesses we have heard from to date for sharing their experiences with us and look forward to working with colleagues on the next phase of the Conference’s work.”

In other findings, 96% of MPs and 69% of their staff members indicated that they had experienced some form of abuse in their role.

Hesitated

One in five MPs said they had “hesitated” about debating or voting on an issue because of the abuse they expected to receive, while 29% said they had considered not standing for re-election for the same reason.

The survey also found that 17% of MPs had considered resigning from public office due to concerns over threatening behaviour and their personal security.

Many staff who responded to the survey said the abuse they or their MP had received had caused them to feel anxious or depressed (42%), or unsafe (48%).

In a series of recommendations, the committee said: “Currently electoral law is not fit for purpose when it comes to tackling harassment, abuse and intimidation of candidates.

“The Government should undertake a full review of electoral law, including identifying practices or processes that unintentionally undermine security or electoral integrity.”

The recommendations “as a minimum” include the removal of the option for home addresses to be published as part of the nomination process for candidates.

The MPs also called for the Government to work with the electoral commission “to review the adequacy of nomination requirements in protecting elections from candidates seeking to mislead the electorate or undermine the integrity of the democratic process”.

Review

The report called for a review to ensure section 106 of the Representation of the People Act 1983, which aims to prevent false statements regarding candidates’ character and conduct, is enforceable and equipped to keep pace with developments in technology such as AI and deepfakes.

The report said the Speaker will work with political parties in Parliament and the Electoral Commission to establish a code of conduct for all candidates, MPs and parties, including a collectively agreed set of “principles to guide behaviours and language when campaigning”.

However, the committee concluded that further security measures “would lead to a fundamental and undesirable change in the way MPs carry out their roles and engage with their constituents”.

It added: “The focus must instead be on encouraging appropriate uptake and effective delivery of existing measures… and reducing the level of threat posed to MPs and candidates, which will be at the centre of the Conference’s second phase of work.”


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

6 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Mab Meirion
Mab Meirion
4 days ago

If only there was a law to protect the public from the death and suffering brought about by the actions of politicians in government starting with a pile of bodies 40 miles high, beating the Byrds by 32 miles…take a bow Fat Shanks…then all the other little mishaps like the poison blood scandal…the Speaker from when he was Fat Shanks’ poodle owes tens of millions of people an apology, some hopes from this one…

Mab Meirion
Mab Meirion
4 days ago
Reply to  Mab Meirion

See the death of Jodey Whiting at the clumsy hands of the DWP…then muse on our inter-married government…sadistic policy thrashed-out during pillow talk…

Jeff
Jeff
4 days ago

yet fartage is out and about claiming all sorts with no censure at a presser today, and his backers don’t really care. Enoch Powell, aka Jenrick is trying to stop fare dodgers despite his past and paint targets on migrants.

How are the speakers gifts going anyway?

Evan Aled Bayton
Evan Aled Bayton
4 days ago

Does this extend to constituents expecting a fair debate rather than fisticuffs as happened in Frodsham recently?

Uhh
Uhh
4 days ago

That’s a bit rich coming from Hoyle…

Chris Hale
Chris Hale
4 days ago

Perhaps if politicians were a little less abusive towards each other, and towards minorities who suffer dogwhistle abuse, they would raise the overall tone of public discourse in this country.

They need to stop seeing themselves as entitled to special treatment.

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.