Welsh Government has had no discussions with Treasury about devolution of Crown Estate
![](https://nation.cymru/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/01J309G9DPJ9RMQRGZ6V7BQP49-scaled-e1721227743710.jpg)
Emily Price
The Welsh Government has had no discussions with the UK Government about devolving the Crown Estate to Wales.
This is despite Labour in Wales consistently claiming it’s a firm commitment of theirs.
The youngest member of the House of Lords, Baroness Carmen Smith, submitted a written question to the Treasury asking for details of any discussions between the administrations in Cardiff Bay and Westminster regarding the issue.
Responding, Labour’s Lord Livermore said: “The UK Government has had no discussions with the Welsh Government on devolving the Crown Estate”.
He added: “The Crown Estate has played a significant role in attracting international investment into Wales to support the UK’s net zero target and will continue to do so through future leasing rounds for offshore wind developments, including floating wind projects in the Celtic Sea.
“They work closely with the Welsh Government and Natural Resources Wales in support of shared priorities, ensuring that these resources are sustainably managed for the long term.
“Introducing a new entity would fragment the market, complicate existing processes, and likely delay further development offshore, undermining investment in Welsh waters.”
The Plaid Cymru peer said the written answer was proof the Welsh Government isn’t “serious” about their claims of seeking the devolution of the Crown Estate to Wales.
Powers
Both the outgoing First Minister Vaughan Gething and Economy Secretary Jeremy Miles said they would back the devolution of the Crown Estate when they were running for the Welsh Labour leadership earlier this year.
Speaking in an interview in February, Mr Gething said: “If I am elected Welsh Labour leader and First Minister, responsibility for the Crown Estate is the most important set of new powers our future Welsh Labour Government would seek for the Senedd.”
Former First Minister Mark Drakeford previously said it could boost the country’s aspirations to become a world leader in renewable energy.
The Crown Estate owns the vast majority of Britain’s seabed, stretching up to 12 nautical miles from the mainland, and leases part of it to wind farm operators.
Profits are paid directly to the Treasury, which then hands on a portion of the money to the monarchy, known as the Sovereign Grant, which supports the official duties of the royal family.
Last year, Nation.Cymru obtained details of the staggering breakdown of Crown Estate assets in Wales.
The group values amounted to a combined worth of £853,030,454.
Plaid Cymru says Wales’ natural resources should be controlled by Wales for the benefit of the communities of Wales – not Westminster.
The party has long called for an arrangement similar to Scotland which would give Wales a direct say in how the profits from new floating wind farms planned off the Welsh coast would be spent.
The estate’s Scottish assets were devolved to Scotland in 2016, and its revenue now goes to the Scottish Government.
‘Vital’
Baroness Smith said: “Keir Starmer promised a ‘reset’ of the UK Government’s relationship with the devolved governments, yet the response of his government to my written question makes clear that what we’re seeing is more of the same.
“Powers over the Crown Estate have been devolved to Scotland since 2017, while Wales has been left voiceless over how profits from renewable energy projects on the Welsh Crown Estate would be spent.
“These powers are vital if we are to ensure that profits made from leasing land for energy projects are retained here in Wales. Plaid Cymru is clear that these profits should be used to address the inequality and poverty facing communities in Wales.”
We contacted incoming First Minister Eluned Morgan and asked whether she had plans to discuss the devolution of the Crown Estate to Wales with the new Labour UK Government.
We did not receive a response.
A Welsh Government spokesperson said: “Our Programme for Government and its commitment to devolving the Crown Estate remains unchanged.
“We want to ensure the Crown Estate works for Wales and we welcome the opportunity to collaborate with the new UK Government on the proposals announced in the King’s Speech.
“Our officials have held initial discussions with their UK Government counterparts on the constitutional reform agenda. These will continue to ensure we maximise the opportunities and benefits for Wales.”
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.
Is anyone surprised? When will the cohort of Labour members and voters who support a Democratic Welsh State wake up and realise that their party acts against our best interests. Join Plaid Cymru and help us get Plaid representatives elected. Then we can start making progress!
It’s about time a Judicial Review was sought to investigate if there is logic in law to pursue this cause and the unjust Barnett Formula, n the courts., to improve the Welsh lot compared to Scotland’s treatment.
This proves that the Welsh Labour government doesn’t give a stuff about Wales. And this is why we need Rhun ap Iorwerth & Plaid Cymru to fight for our interests because previous First Ministers such as Carwyn Jones, Mark Drakeford, Vaughan Gething & Eluned Morgan are basically naval-gazers only interested in being subservient to their London masters. We have natural resource but like our water Wales is being used & abused by the English Monarchy & Westminster Treasury making hundreds of millions off our backs and we receive bloody nothing. What other country in the would allow this to occur… Read more »
God save the King.
Indeed. Only God can.
Will God save prince Andrew?
I don’t think that the Labour party, at any time in its history, really has the will to set itself against the Crown. At the least, while some of its mavericks might, its mainstream definitely won’t.
This cannot go on. Parity with Scotland now. We have a lot of 12 miles out along a lot of coastline. Our country is being extorted full stop and it must end.
Over to you Eluned
Not even a bare minimum policy to pass the revenues to Llywodraeth Cymru? That alone speaks volumes.
They’ve said the quiet part out loud:
“Crown Estate has played a significant role in attracting international investment into Wales to support the UK’s net zero target and will continue to do so”
That is, UK interests override Welsh interests
It was never in doubt that WG never approached UK govt and even less likely they will if the noble Lady is running the show.
The reason why the crown estate assets in Scotland was devolved was because the Scottish SNP government demanded control and ownership of the assets should be owned by the Scottish nation. The Welsh government’s duty to the people of Cymru is to demand from the UK government control and ownership of our assets so that they are owned by the our nation Cymru. We must dismantle this regime of colonialism between our country and UK/England and create a partnership of equals. It cannot continue as present – It doesn’t work for either ! There is no fair and just partnership… Read more »