Opinion

Beyond the climate emergency: Why Wales should grow trees for timber, jobs and affordable homes

17 Nov 2021 6 minutes Read
Gary Newman.

Gary Newman, Woodknowledge Wales

Change is afoot. That much is clear to anyone who followed the COP26 proceedings. Encouraging words and promises must now be followed by action. Action at home to be precise. Research by Climate Action Tracker demonstrates temperatures are likely to rise 2.4-degrees Celsius this century, a long way from a 1.5-degrees Celsius future that we hope avoids the worst effects of climate change.

Wales is a country of immense beauty and cultural heritage. Wales is also one of the poorest countries in Europe, with some of the most deprived communities. Despite this, Wales – like all European countries – is a high consumption society and needs to assume responsibility for the climate emergency we find ourselves in today.

Sorting social injustice while acting on carbon emissions is something we owe to our communities.

None of this is new. What strikes us as different is the broad commitment to change and to co-create a better future for the people and the planet. This is where our land, our trees and our forests come in.

What if our homes are part of the solution?

The built environment – our homes, offices, streets – is a major contributor to Welsh carbon emissions. And is a key area where we urgently need to act. In fact, the recently published Welsh Development Quality requirements 2021 – which set standards in Social Housing – has significantly raised the bar for social landlords to deliver zero carbon homes.

What if we could change our built environment from a carbon emitter to a carbon store, and by doing so create local jobs in rural communities? What if we could use a natural resource that is readily available in Wales to achieve this today – and for future generations?

This is what the Home-Grown Homes Project set out to explore in 2018, and what we are currently working on with local councils, housing associations, architects and designers, manufacturers, sawmillers and land owners.

Why focus on tree planting and timber production in Wales?

Wales needs more housing and better performing housing. Wales needs local jobs for local people, especially in rural areas. Wales also has some of the finest forests, growing some of the best quality timber. Timber is a low-carbon material. High-performing timber homes can be constructed fast, at scale and at affordable cost. Welsh timber businesses – from sawmillers to joiners to housing manufacturers – are rooted in communities and have the potential to expand and innovate, thereby creating jobs and developing skills where they are needed.

To us, this sounds like a list of ingredients to create a resilient post-Covid post-Brexit economy, a recipe for positive change even without the urgency to act on carbon emissions.

So, what is missing to turn this into a nationwide success story?

Although we grow some of the finest wood in the world, Wales imports the majority of its timber. In fact, the UK is the second largest importer of timber products in the world after China. So far, we’ve been very comfortable with assuming other countries will provide our timber. We take pride in being a steel, beef and dairy nation without acknowledging that we are also a forest nation, with abundant woodlands in Powys, the Borders and North Wales and with an internationally acclaimed forestry research centre at Bangor university.

With current constraints on construction material, massive price increases and global demand for timber set to quadruple, we shouldn’t be relying on timber from other parts of the world. We need to invest in our own land and the people who work with it to ensure a reliable supply of the materials we need in our future low carbon society.

Growing a home every four minutes

Anyone will be forgiven for not associating Wales with forests and woodlands. Only 15 per cent of Wales is covered in trees against a continental European average of 37 per cent. Nonetheless, the existing Welsh forest grows enough timber of the right grade to create a new timber home, every four minutes. It would take 20 days for the 7,000 Welsh homes to grow that we need to build every year to meet our housing needs.

Unfortunately, at present, only 4 per cent of the Welsh harvest finds its way into construction. Using timber in construction, especially for structural purposes, is the most environmentally beneficial use for that timber.

Instead, our timber mostly goes into relatively low value products, such as fencing, pallets and garden sleepers – products with a much shorter lifespan.

Investing in those working with the land

Over the past 50 years, we have built relatively little with timber in Wales. More recently, the demand to deliver energy-efficient, zero-carbon homes at scale and at affordable cost has sparked an increase in timber construction, especially in the social housing sector.

This demand now needs to be reflected in higher investment in forestry – planting and growing the trees that will supply the timber we need in the future.

Investment and the call for grants is often mentioned. Yet, money is only part of the answer. Most of the land in Wales is owned by farmers. Farmers are key to our food supply in Wales and will be the key to any increase in tree planting for timber.

From a landowner’s view, the decision to engage in forestry is not to be taken lightly. Land needs to be suitable. Growing trees for timber needs to be commercially viable, compared to other land uses that provide income to farmers and their communities.

We urgently need to support our farmers in assessing if tree planting makes sense for them, as well as for society. Becoming a tree farmer requires knowledge and a different set of skills but is well within the abilities of people used to working with the land.

To grow enough timber for future generations and help Wales become a country with a thriving future, we have set out five essential strategies in our Home-Grown Homes Project.

But for any significant change to happen we will need all hands-on deck. From farmers and foresters, to sawmillers and joiners, building developers and designers, and finally communities and residents.

We will require bold policy decisions to enable action on all levels involved – and support from all political parties and all corners of the country.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
6 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Andrew
Andrew
17 days ago

As long as it’s not the timber farm spruce types of forest that already blight our land. They support zero wildlife, leave the soil acidic and leave the land looking like a post apocalyptic scene after harvest. The soil is then washed away afterwards. We already have a problem with foreign corporations buying up entire farms and doing this to offset their carbon footprint.This land thereafter will never be good to grow crops or graze animals. Perhaps it may be better to support our native farms and farmers to make our little nation self sufficient and cancelling all the air… Read more »

John Henry
John Henry
16 days ago

This is pure greenwash. Geoengineering like this is not the answer to the climate crisis. To do that we need to stop using fossil fuels now. It is an illusion to think that schemes such as these are anything but tinkering around the edge of the climate problem. It should go without saying that we need a sustainable forestry strategy, one that encourages flora and fauna diversity. We don’t need a voracious extractive industry that will smother endless acres of Wales in monocultural conifer plantations. That is the hidden message in this corporate advertorial .

Malcolm rj
Malcolm rj
16 days ago

Leave our wonderful Wales and country free from more trees they are going to cover a wide parts of Wales with windmills now. they should use our gift from God tides that are the second highest in the world around Wales

defaid
defaid
13 days ago

I love the fact that the first link in this article takes the reader to a photo of mechanised harvesting of a conifer plantation…

How long will the “immense beauty and cultural hetitage” last under a blanket of Picea ikeaensis? Gary, you’re barking up the wrong tree: this is just corporate advertisement.

defaid
defaid
13 days ago

Britain currently imports 90% of our timber requirement. We also import 100% of our banana requirement. If we devoted enough land to industrial greenhouses then we could become self sufficient in bananas, thus making a world-leading saving in banana carbon miles…

Here are some statistics, from Forest Research and from the WG…

England: 10% forest cover, of which 26% is conifer

Scotland: 19% forested, of which 75% is conifer, mostly non-native

Wales: 15% forest cover, of which 67% is conifer, pretty well entirely non-native.

CapM
CapM
11 days ago

One of the reasons we import softwood timber is because our winters are much milder than for example Scandinavian ones which results in the structure of a lot of our timber being less strong. Therefore it is less suitable for structural uses or home grown timber of larger dimensions must be substituted. Even just a 10% increase in joist depth would mean a significant increase in other building materials and costs. With climate change it’s predicted that our winters will get milder resulting in even less of our home grown timber being suitable for structural purposes. “Although we grow some… Read more »

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.