“… but could we afford it?”

Adam Ramsay
When I was asking people in mid-Wales last year how they felt about independence for my new book, Abolish Westminster, the same question came up again and again.
Coming from Scotland, I generally found the tone of the conversations refreshing. At home, this debate can often be pretty polarised. Most people already have a view either way. Many of those I spoke to in Wales – particularly younger and left-leaning voters – had a more flirtatious relationship with the notion.
They had neither committed to nor outright rejected the idea. And, with polling and Plaid Cymru on the rise, it felt like they were actually thinking about it for the first time.
But they always came back to that question. “Could we afford it?”
It’s always tempting to give a glib answer: eight centuries of rule by the British state have left you the poorest country in Northern Europe. You can’t afford to let that continue.
The slightly longer argument comes in multiple forms.
You can look at it politically.
European countries which usually elect leftist or leftish governments are generally the best places in the world to live. Wales, despite having a voting record similar to that of a Nordic country, has had right-wing governments imposed on it for most of the last two hundred years. As a result, it is much poorer than these neighbours. And significantly less equal.
In recent decades, as England has struggled to get over losing the empire, being Scottish or Welsh has been a little like being a passenger in a car driven by someone having a nervous breakdown. It’s perfectly rational to ask to get out and make your own way.
Extraction
You can make the old argument about extraction. For generation after generation, Westminster has sucked wealth and youth and energy from Wales, leaving your domestic economy to wither.
It’s not original to point to the way that transport routes run out of Wales, built to carry coal and slate and youth to the imperial core. But for the book, I tried to think about the daily money flows from Welsh people’s bank accounts.
Where are mortgage payments going, and electricity bills, and supermarket spends? More and more of people’s spending is flowing out of Wales and onto the balance sheets of a small number of vast multinational corporations, almost none of which have their headquarters and their highest-paying jobs in Wales.
Admiral Group plc is the only FTSE 100 company to be officially registered in Wales, and in reality, its better-paid jobs are generally done out of its Gibraltar office, meaning that the daily reality of the modern Welsh economy is that a vast portion of the wealth created in Wales is transferred out of Wales, to fund high managerial salaries in offices, usually in the south-east of England.
More devolution
It can be tempting to think that more devolution might solve this. Perhaps, by handing more powers to vary tax rates, manage the railways and govern the Crown Estate, for example, the Welsh Government could generate more domestic industry, ensuring more of the wealth created in Wales would continue to circulate in Wales instead of flowing out of the country.
There are three problems with this.
Firstly, it leaves fundamental macroeconomic questions about things like how much you can invest in infrastructure up to the blind ideologues at the Treasury, whose aversion to state investment has held Britain back for generations now.
As I set out in the book, senior Treasury officials brag about how their department has had the same free-market doctrine for at least 150 years, whichever governments we elect. In practice, this has left the UK with some of the lowest investment rates in the developed world. If you’re the City of London, this free marketeer’s version of economic management is wonderful. If you’re Wales, it’s a disaster.
The Treasury is a vast, millennium-old agglomeration of power, which, because of the archaic design of the British state, faces remarkably little accountability from the MPs we elect. It is, on the other hand, hugely influenced by the financial services industry. Even with more devolution, it would still (as we’ve found in Scotland) retain vast power over the Welsh economy. You need to free yourself from it.
While this is particularly true of the Treasury, it’s also true of other institutions of the British state which would inevitably retain enormous power over the Welsh economy in any devolution scenario. The Department for Business and Trade is much more accountable to big businesses than it is to MPs, never mind to Welsh representatives. Even if an independent Wales were to join the EU, the Welsh Government would have more say over trade deals affecting Wales than it currently does. Likewise, the Bank of England is deeply embedded in the City.
Lent
Secondly, devolved powers are lent, not given. As we’ve discovered in Scotland, they will be clawed back when it’s politically convenient. This isn’t to say that more devolution is meaningless. The Institute for Fiscal Studies has calculated that the poorest families with children in Scotland are £2,000 a year richer than their equivalents in England because of how the Scottish Government has used devolved powers over the social security system.
But on everything from trans rights to a deposit return scheme for bottles and cans which the drinks industry didn’t like, if the powerful can generate a tabloid moral panic against a policy, they can bait Westminster into blocking it. Really getting to grips with Welsh poverty will require genuinely confronting vested interests. Those same interests have huge influence in the corridors of Westminster and Whitehall.
Within Britain, the “crown in parliament” – that is, Westminster plus the king’s power as expressed in theory through the cabinet and in reality through government departments – is sovereign. From the electoral system to the corporate capture of the two main parties it produces, from the tight whipping system to the crony-stuffed House of Lords, and from the revolving door between Whitehall and the big consultancy firms to their addiction to outsourcing, this isn’t a network of power and influence which you want to have the final say over how your community works.
Constitution
Ultimately – and this is the third reason – the British state was built to run the biggest empire in human history. Its constitution, something the ruling class makes up as it goes along, is the legal underpinning which allowed our ruling class to transform the remnants of colonialism – the British Virgin Islands, the Cayman Islands, Bermuda, Gibraltar, Guernsey, Jersey and Mann – into the world’s most important laundry for criminal money. And, as I set out in the book, they are much more than that. Offshore Britain, along with the City of London, is a vital part of the plumbing for liquid finance everywhere.
A vast portion of the world’s capital flows through British territory each year, much of it syphoned into the accounts of the bloating oligarch class which is hoping to drown democracies everywhere in dark money.
Race to the bottom
Wales isn’t unique in being a victim of an economic system built on extractivism. Much of the world is. And offshore Britain, protected by the British state, is an important part of the machinery of extraction. For two generations now, it’s led the race to the bottom in corporate taxes and regulation which has scuttled all attempts to build a fairer future.
But as England’s first colony, Wales is almost unique in its capacity to force the people of these islands to take a final step out of the long shadow of empire. It’s time for Wales, Scotland, a united Ireland and England to shed our absurd state system and join the world as a family of modern, properly democratic, independent nations. We can’t afford not to.
Adam Ramsay’s book Abolish Westminster is available now in all good bookshops, or at any of these links. He also edits the new website abolishwestminster.com.
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.
Get more trusted Welsh news
Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News to see more of our journalism.

