Support our Nation today - please donate here
Opinion

Devolution, my arse! – a Budget 2026 post on rail in Wales

31 Oct 2026 5 minute read
An artist’s impression of the proposed Cardiff Parkway railway station. Credit: WilkinsonEyre.

Professor Mark Barry

As you all know, rail in Wales is non-devolved and has suffered billions of pounds of relative underfunding by UK Governments over the last 25 years!

This has also meant that, to progress rail schemes like the South Wales Metro, the Welsh Government has had to use funds from its block grant meant for health, education, etc., to make up the shortfall.

My last report for the Senedd Research team is worth a read: Hey, Andy, time to devolve rail to Wales!

This week’s Budget was an opportunity for the UK Government to begin to address this long-standing issue with some serious capital commitment to Wales’s rail network. What we have is £30m towards Cardiff Parkway station (yes, welcome), which will cost at least £60m. This takes the current UK Government commitment to rail enhancements in Wales in the current Comprehensive Spending Review (CSR) period to 2030 to approximately £350m. This contrasts with approximately £34bn committed to rail enhancements in England over the same period.

PS: I may have got that wrong. It now seems the Cardiff Parkway £30m announcement is just to confirm that this station is part of the Burns stations’ scope, and no extra money has yet been allocated compared with what was set out in the CSR… so just £305m for Wales in this four-year period to 2030. They must be laughing at us in Whitehall… and most in Welsh Labour are suffering from Stockholm syndrome! (As manifested in the exchanges during oral questions to the Westminster Transport Minister at 10am on October 29, 2026.)

Seriously, does anyone think this is good enough – especially those in Welsh Labour who used to vociferously make the case for change? The oft-talked-about £14bn does not exist on any HM Treasury spreadsheet and is the rail equivalent of the Emperor’s New Clothes.

If the UK Government were taking this funding inequity seriously, it would have acted on at least some of my proposals here: Wales Rail Enhancement Priorities for UK Government, October 2026.

Just £30m tells us all we need to know. What about more funds for the schemes already announced in the CSR, which will cost over £700m (not £305m), more funds to begin detailed scheme development for the first phases of Swansea Metro, further work on Borderlands/Merseyrail integration and the North Wales Main Line (NWML)… and, yes, of course, fixing Metro in Cardiff? But no, nothing! Waiting for politically compromised Westminster largesse is never going to work for rail in Wales!

To make matters worse, sources tell me that there has been little or no progress on improving Wales’s position regarding the current GB Railways Bill.

Unsurprisingly, most of the obfuscation is coming from the rail industry ecosystem in England, which can’t bear to give up “their” train set – forgetting, of course, that they are custodians of a public asset in Wales!!

This entirely predictable situation reflects the patronising and dismissive attitude we in Wales often face when dealing with Whitehall bureaucracy. It is not helped by Westminster politicians from Wales, who generally don’t understand, or are not inclined to engage with, the relevant details.

With Andy Burnham talking up devolution, one could be forgiven for thinking that we would see much more progress as far as Wales is concerned. However, disappointingly, I think Jim Royle (a famous Manchester resident whom I am sure Andy Burnham is familiar with) would put the current situation most appropriately: “Devolution, my arse.”

My advice to the Welsh Government is to stop playing nice with the UK Government and refuse to recommend legislative consent for the rail bill in the Senedd. My advice to Welsh Labour is to “grow some”!

Wales needs nothing less than a fully devolved and fairly funded settlement for rail infrastructure. Like Jim said, anything else: my arse!

PS: What the UK Government could have done…

Said…

“You know, we should really have funded all of the South Wales Metro, given that rail funding is a reserved matter… so here’s another £500m to help. Sorry about that funding dysfunction.”

“You know, we should probably fund Cardiff Crossrail Phase 1a in full… and make a start on 1b and Phase 2… here’s £300m.”

“We’d also like to accelerate work to deliver four trains per hour on Borderlands and integrate with Merseyrail, AND accelerate line speed and capacity upgrades on the NWML. How about £200m to get going?”

“Oh, and another £500m to make progress on Burns stations and services (you need to order some more rolling stock, don’t you? Best not delay that) – we might be able to get four or five of those delivered by 2030.”

“… And we could start detailed design and development in Swansea for its metro… here’s £50m, so we can start implementation work in 2030.”

“Oh, and I think, yes, you are right: Wales also deserves a vertically integrated and simplified rail ecosystem like the GBR Bill will deliver for England via GBR. So yes, we’ll amend the bill to fully devolve rail and then align GBR Cymru with TfW.”

Etc.

But they didn’t… and they probably never will. This ought to get ugly!

This article was first published on Mark’s blog


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.


Get more trusted Welsh news

Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News to see more of our journalism.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

18 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Richard Jenkins
Richard Jenkins
17 days ago

Devolution achieving its design brief ? Total failure?

Dom
Dom
17 days ago

The opposite. This is a story of failed central government control.

Ryan S
Ryan S
17 days ago
Reply to  Dom

Hard disagree. The opportunity for devolution of railway infrastructure was turned down by WG. As much, if not more of a failure with devolved governments – especially not being ambitious enough. Just like last week when plaid opted not for council tax rebranding when they’ve spent past 10 years asking for major reform.
we need more boldness in our politicians in wales. And to stop constantly blaming Westminster, especially when for some of these issues, the buck stops with us

Dom
Dom
17 days ago
Reply to  Ryan S

Devolution should be about making better choices with the same money, but it turns out that the best argument for devolution is getting any money spent at all.

Undecided
Undecided
15 days ago
Reply to  Ryan S

Correct. It’s no good claiming we wuz robbed, when the reality is that we robbed ourselves.

Richard Jenkins
Richard Jenkins
17 days ago
Reply to  Dom

Exactly! Devolution totally controlled centrally was never going to work!

Nigel
Nigel
16 days ago

How do you come to that conclusion?

Brychan
Brychan
17 days ago

Wales is not on the list of Labour Party priorities for rail. There were two major announcements made for funding by the Westminster government, (a) a new railway station for Bradford and (b) a complete re-build of Leeds City Station at £303m. This is part of the ‘Northern PowerHouse Rail’ project with a total spend of £45bn in upgrades. The Labour Party just shunted Wales into the sidings.

Dom
Dom
17 days ago
Reply to  Brychan

It’s not going to help them keep councils in May when Bristol’s had seven new or upgraded stations vs nothing except artists impressions for Cardiff.

Ryan S
Ryan S
17 days ago

The author clearly is an expert in this area. Infrastructure is important – but this is less than a half of railway expenditure. The more meaningful comparison is to consider the WG subsidy to TfW and the uk government subsidy to network rail and to compare to england. Always worth remembering all railways receives massive government subsidies. Far more than buses despite fewer users. my brother works for network rail as a manager and I asked him this once. His reply was wales is 25% underfunded or 50% overfunded depending on what statistic you pick (track length, passenger numbers, revenue,… Read more »

Dom
Dom
17 days ago
Reply to  Ryan S

No serious commentator uses the consequences of underfunding (low passenger numbers) to justify further underfunding.

Mark Barry
Mark Barry
17 days ago
Reply to  Ryan S

A little naeive. WG is responsible for the majority of rail ops subsidy in Wales out of it’s block grant….but is not formally responsible for investment in the underlying infrastructure that may make our rail ops more efficient and attractive to passengers. My focus on rail infra and especially enhancement funding is very valid…as a more enhanced railway can carry more passengers more efficiently. If you are in any doubt of the gross inequity then read the relevant chapters in my book AND my last report on capital funding for Senedd research which used and pivoted off ORR data. (I… Read more »

Ryan S
Ryan S
16 days ago
Reply to  Mark Barry

No offence – but I’m not going to read your book, I’ve got a job, and with the greatest respect, better things to do! but if you want, I’ll read your book – so long as you read my book- but to warn you in advance it is on engineering physics! I’m happy to be considered naive; I agree I am, but specifically on your comment – I agree that infrastructure is relevant- but the operating cost and subsidy are equally relevant if we are trying to establish the full extent of under or overfunding compared to regions of England-… Read more »

Mark Barry
Mark Barry
16 days ago
Reply to  Ryan S

Thnx – I think you, like many, are missing the essential point re the devolved settlement and funding thereof which generates the essential capital funding dysfunction. This results from the “reserved powers ” status of rail infrastructure vs the operational costs and subsidy via TfW (ignoring the GWR, Avanti and CrossCountry service) , which is in effect “devolved”. (You’d never run a business like this!) This is not a rail ops issue – its a constitutional and governmental funding issue. Too many in the rail industry fail to recognise this essential dysfunction. I don’t mind that you won’t read my… Read more »

Ryan S
Ryan S
16 days ago
Reply to  Mark Barry

Thanks- and fair on the physics. You will survive my book better than I would yours! But I don’t think I’m missing a constitutional point. I accept it entirely. Infrastructure is not devolved and operations effectively are. But that’s an argument about who controls the money – not how much wales gets. My point is narrower. If we want to compare whether Wales is underfunded (or overfunded!) we have to count everything that’s spent on railway not just the funding stream that supports our political views. You’ve said that the opex/subsidy comes out of the block grant. That’s a bit… Read more »

Mark Barry
Mark Barry
16 days ago
Reply to  Ryan S

Thnx – I still think you are missing a piece here. But not sure this is the best forum! More than happy to meet and talk if that helps. Also PS the WG subsidy to rail ops in Wales is circa £300m pa (bus is circa £200M)…..vs say Health which is over £12Bn pa…
R Mark

Anne Wareham
Anne Wareham
12 days ago

Not much point in doing anything for railways when people living miles from stations can’t park anywhere near a railway station.

Askevans
Askevans
9 days ago

Just as an extra point for your arguement all the Welsh schemes you list (and at least one was Anglo Welsh) add up to what Welsh rail should get if it rail spending was done per head of population

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.