In an independent Wales, a Welsh Central Bank must play an active role in a wellbeing economy

William Thomson and Warren Mosler
An opportunity exists to create a central bank that reflects Wales’s unique economic landscape.
We believe a Welsh Central Bank (WCB) in an independent Wales should be central to a framework for implementing a wellbeing economy.
We propose a democratic institution focused on full employment, reducing income and wealth inequality, directing resources to the real economy, and supporting an economy and society that operate within planetary boundaries.
In our recent policy paper, “A Scottish Central Bank for an independent Scotland”, in which we proposed a very different central bank for Scotland, we also had Wales in mind.
In 2025, we met with policymakers in Wales and wrote articles for Nation.Cymru. It is very much the case that what is good for Scotland’s wellbeing economy is essential for Wales.
If a wellbeing economy were the destination for an independent Wales, the central bank would have at least one foot on the pedal.
A new Wales would need a new central bank, but would mirroring the Bank of England steer Wales towards a wellbeing economy?
The answer is clearly not. In fact, few issues unite so many monetary economists as dissatisfaction with how central banks, including the Bank of England (BoE), operate. Their large balance sheets (swollen by quantitative easing – swapping central bank liabilities like reserve balances and government bonds with commercial debt) have given them a larger footprint in the economy than anyone ever imagined.
To give an idea of the ‘new normal’, from 2008 to the end of 2014, the US Federal Reserve’s balance sheet grew from $900 billion to $4.5 trillion. The BoE’s grew from £98 billion to £407 billion.
Interest payments on the balances commercial banks hold at the central bank have also ballooned. In 2025, the BoE paid £25bn in interest. A decade earlier, the figure was under £2bn. This is a choice that the UK Government and its central bank are making.
There is an alternative. The Swiss National Bank operates a tiered system in which reserves above a specified threshold receive a rate below the policy rate. Sweden’s Riksbank pays no interest at all on a proportion of deposits held at the central bank. This is the direction of travel for small European nations.
Finally, there is what many consider the most significant problem: an increasingly blurred boundary between monetary and fiscal functions, as technocrats decide some of the most political issues, including redistribution and the level of unemployment.
We suggest that replicating these conditions would significantly disrupt progress towards a wellbeing economy that aims to reduce income inequality, direct resources to the real economy and be led by democratic institutions.
A new Welsh Central Bank for a new Wales
We started with a blank sheet of paper, a luxury Wales will have when it is independent. We advocate a limited, small-balance-sheet model that relies on neither bond markets nor asset purchases, resolving many of the institutional tensions that plague the BoE and other central banks. In one sense, we offer a ‘less is more’ answer to an orthodox and heterodox economic puzzle.
Some commentators on Nation.Cymru have argued that Wales should not only seek to copy the institutional design of the UK’s core financial institutions but should also keep the Bank of England as Wales’s central bank for an extended period. This is the template grabbed from the SNP in Holyrood.
Given the concerns expressed by orthodox and heterodox economists and central bankers about current arrangements, this would likely strike the reader as a bizarre starting premise for a new central bank. Given the opportunity, no central banker would design a new bank based on the status quo, especially when considering how to construct the very different economic system of a wellbeing economy.
There is an opportunity to create a central bank that reflects Wales’s unique economic landscape. That is the challenge we set ourselves.
Currency and the central bank
Central to our argument is that, in a modern monetary economy, you cannot disentangle the creation of a central bank from the issuance of a sovereign fiat currency. One is not possible without the other. You could have an organisation called a Welsh Central Bank, but operationally, you can launch a WCB only by creating a Welsh currency.
Within three years of a vote for independence, a WCB could be fully operational and overseeing a fiat currency issued by the Welsh Government. This is certainly an accelerated timetable compared with those proposed by other commentators, but we believe it is realistic.
What would a Welsh central bank do?
Our proposal is for a Welsh Central Bank that operates on the general understanding that a central bank issues a fiat currency, issues notes and coins, oversees the payment system, sets the base interest rate, oversees or is directly involved in regulating the financial sector and, crucially, acts as the lender of last resort.
This is the traditional role of a central bank; however, our design does not cling to an outdated understanding of monetary operations and institutions. It sets out a WCB that actively supports a wellbeing economy.
A Welsh Central Bank for a wellbeing economy
A Welsh Central Bank would have a minimal balance sheet. It would not use the unemployed as a buffer for price stability – the policy framework that dominates central banks at the moment – or make large, regressive interest payments on government liabilities.
It would provide unlimited but strongly regulated liquidity, would not use fiscal space for foreign reserve accumulation, and would place full employment at the heart of its mandate. It would also provide full bank deposit insurance and would not constrain its operations with capital targets.
If central banks are indeed the ‘only game in town’ in today’s modern economy, they do not need to be built on an orthodox understanding of monetary operations. For Wales, independence is a unique opportunity for an institutional reset.
Rather than inheriting UK financial structures and monetary policy functions, Wales can instead design a central bank that supports full employment, price stability and resilience, aligned with the concept of a wellbeing economy. Our policy paper would be a foundational piece of that puzzle.
William Thomson and Warren Mosler’s policy paper, A Scottish Central Bank for an independent Scotland: A review of the Scottish Government’s current proposal and an outline of a wellbeing economy alternative, provides a useful framework for a central bank in an independent Wales.
William Thomson worked for almost a decade in the financial services sector in London, holding positions at the British Bankers’ Association and the Council of Mortgage Lenders. William has an MA (Hons), an MSc in the Green Economy and an MEcon in Economics of Sustainability. He is the founder of Scotland’s Economics Festival and the think-and-do tank Resilient Economy.
Warren Mosler has worked in banking and financial markets for over fifty years. Warren founded Modern Monetary Theory (MMT), a new school of economics that grew out of his practical understanding of how central banks, governments and commercial banks operate. He has written extensively on central banking, government finance, monetary systems and how independent fiat currencies operate.
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.


Complete fantasy.
Is there an example of this proposal being successfully achieved elsewhere, or is the author proposing an experiment.
Yes, Dom, there is. The most of the world circa 1946 – 1976… The complete failure of the neoliberal economics introduced by Thatcher/Howe (and Reagan in the US) is evidenced by the subsequent declines in, for example, health, education and environmental quality. All based on a fantastical interpretation of microeconomics that has no theoretical or real-world basis. Hence the notions of the government-as-household, counter-productive fiscal rules, non-existent taxpayers’ money, balanced budgets, the growth fetish, the ineffectual use of interest rates to manage inflation and much else. The subsidies for the private sector have perverted the engine that the state sector… Read more »
Talking about an example of a small country becoming independent and successfully creating a new central bank on the proposed basis. Not talking about the absurdity of neoliberalism that ended up killing capitalism.
Ah…
These references may be helpful, Dom…
About the Bank – Bank of GhanaBank of Ghanahttps://www.bog.gov.gh › about-the-bank
https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/media/research/monthly_review/1964_pdf/07_4_64.pdf
Cymru’s Central Bank will of course be tailored to the particular conditions that the country faces and its economic objectives.
Ghana is an orthodox central bank. It doesn’t have anything to do with MMT.
We have to get out of the habit of looking for analogies to ‘prove’ arguments. Every country is different. We need to analyse our own circumstances.
The post-war period is not comparable. Although independent countries had their own central banks, their exchange rates were fixed to the dollar which in turn was linked to gold until Nixon ended the US promise to convert dollars to gold. That is not what this article is proposing.
With respect, I consider your point as largely irrelevant to the main issue, Lyn E.
‘Central to our argument is that, in a modern monetary economy, you cannot disentangle the creation of a central bank from the issuance of a sovereign fiat currency.’
The dollar exchange system was not based on fiat currencies.
The current budgetary and social crises in France illustrates how a country without control over its own money faces an additional constraint in taking steps to resolve those. But this article offers wishful thinking rather than a rigorous examination of the challenges that would face an independent Wales with its own central bank and how those might be confronted. We need deeper analysis of the real-world context in which a Welsh Central Bank would operate, not just an idealised model of how it might.
I’ll post further comments considering some examples from the article.
The article correctly points to the savings that could be obtained by reducing the interest paid by a central bank to commercial banks. But Welsh independence is not strictly necessary to achieve that. It used to be normal for central banks not to pay such interest, and the New Economics Foundation has estimated that several billion pounds a year could be saved by the Bank of England if it reverted to reserve requirements or introduced tiered interest. There is a case that an independent Wales might not be as politically subservient to the city of London but many countries have… Read more »
‘We started with a blank sheet of paper, a luxury Wales will have when it is independent.’ There could be no clearer statement of how this article is an academic exercise, not yet a proposal for the real world. Wales will face many constraints. A relevant example is that an independent Wales would inherit a yet to be negotiated share of UK debt denominated in sterling. As many countries have found, liability for debt in a foreign currency can place serious limits on economic choices. Converting that debt to Welsh currency could come at prohibitive interest rates. Although… Read more »
Lyn E, you say that an independent Wales would inherit a yet to be negotiated share of UK debt denominated in sterling. This does not appear to be correct. When there were exchanges between the UK and Scottish governments on this point prior to the referendum, the former advised that an independent Scotland would not be permitted a share of the so-called national debt. As the latter is in fact an asset, this was not altogether surprising. I would therefore anticipate the same would hold in respect of an independent Cymru. Sensible economic management would see Cymrian government operating budget… Read more »
National debt is an asset for those who hold bonds but it is a debt for the state. The clue is in the name. You are confusing debt with debt instruments. This is what the UK government paper on ‘UK debt and the Scotland independence referendum’ says about debt transfer: ‘1.1 In the event of Scottish independence from the United Kingdom (UK), the continuing UK Government would in all circumstances honour the contractual terms of the debt issued by the UK Government. An independent Scottish state would become responsible for a fair and proportionate share of the UK’s current liabilities,… Read more »
All the points you make are based on UK government proposals, They are not the terms of any agreement on debt. They are not conditions of Independence or even how the debt factor will be decided, that takes both sides to agree as the Vienna Convention mkaes clear. The dept, nor the negotiating positions can be imposed by the remaining state, the state responsible for the debt. Nor are you correct that the resolution would be in sterling. Wales has no deb and any agreement on compensation, for that is what it would be, would be in Wales own currency.
I agree this all needs to be negotiated. I was challenging the claim that the UK government had agreed that Scotland would not inherit any of the UK’s national debt. I doubt the UK government would accept being repaid in a new and unproven currency as its own creditors will expect sterling.
I believe that in its proposals, the UK is merely proposing a wish. What is being argued in other posts is that the debt on secession lies entirely with the UK. That is a position acknowledged on the UK Treasury letter. Any negotiations by Scotland, and Wales, would be on the basis of how they see any responsibilities they have towards the debt. Your arguments give too much weight to the UK position. As for currency. I doubt that Wales would would accept making any payment in a foreign currency and as the Vienna Convention states. No agreement on the… Read more »
Article 40 (1) of the Vienna Convention 1983 states,
‘When part or parts of the territory of a State separate from that State and form a State, and
unless the predecessor State and the successor State otherwise agree, the State debt of the predecessor State shall pass to the successor State in an equitable proportion, taking into account, in particular, the property, rights and interests which pass to the successor State in relation to that State debt.’
So. Your point is?
You appeared to claim that the entirety of the UK’s debt on the separation of Wales would stay with the UK but the Vienna Convention says it should be split in an ‘equitable proportion’. There is of course plenty of scope to negotiate exactly what that means.
Yes that’s exactley what i am saying. As you are aware, there is no international law or regulation on the division of debt on secession. The Vienna Convention has issued guidelines, respected guidlines, but nevertheless guidlines. The legal and accepted position with regard to the UK debt is that it will remain the responsibility of the remaining state, the issuer of the bonds. UKr. All else is the subject of negotiation. The main points in the Vienna Convention is fairness and that and agreement cannot be imposed. Although some like to cherry pick the Conventions guidance it is wide ranging.… Read more »
If England (let’s drop UKr as the UK will no longer exist if it breaks up) inherits the UK’s legal obligations then, as the continuation state, it would indeed be expected to honour the contractual obligations of the UK, including debt repayment (as the UKG statement acknowledges). But that is just a starting point for negotiations. Unless England is feeling particularly generous then it will expect to be reimbursed for an ‘equitable’ share of that debt, whatever that might be, and in sterling. England, as the continuation state, would have ownership rights over all UK assets. We may well think… Read more »
Now you are getting deluded. This image you have of England striding the world doing as it wishes. That’s long gone. The mind boggles at all these ‘ thousands ‘ of treaties that Wales will need to join and more, get Eanglands permmossion to join is fantasy. In your world the treaties negotiated as UK, now as common old England it may well themselves have to rejoin. Cerainly their seat in the UN would be in jeopardy. As for your argument on assets and currency are concerned. No share of assets, no share of debt. I think Wales could live… Read more »
Sorry, but you are the fantasist here, not me. Far from believing that ‘England can do as it wishes, my thinking about this is influenced by the UK’s failure to get what it thought it could out of the post-Brexit negotiations with the EU, hence my reference to Johnson. Anyone seriously interested in the practicalities of Wales becoming independent should study the results of those negotiations, see how little Britain got, and how hard it has been to diverge from EU regulations in many areas even where it would be legally possible. The issues around the land border in… Read more »
I have no objection in principle to capital controls but there would be practical difficulties in sustaining those between Wales and England given the high interaction between them. I expect people and businesses in Wales would wish to hold sterling assets given the need to make sterling payments and the uncertainty around future exchange rates. Similarly, I doubt people and businesses in Wales will welcome obstacles to free trade and movement across the new border. We have seen the effects of Brexit. I don’t ever want to need documentation to visit my friends and family. I doubt an independence vote… Read more »
One of the most sensible posts I’ve read on this site. It does make me laugh that people seem to think that we (or Scotland) can just walk away from the UK and not take on a single penny of its debt. Even if we found some loophole, we would have destroyed relations with our closest ally and trading partner forever.
The debt question usually takes one of two extreme positions (no inherited debt or a population share of all UK debt) but both are wrong. Each individual debt needs to be assessed individually. Some may entirely transfer such as the borrowing used to pay for the promised £14bn Welsh rail investment. Other debts might be done on a population share, perhaps old war bonds. But no-one could argue that an independent Wales would still owe 5% of the money borrowed to build Crossrail or the £40bn refurbish the Palace of Westminster that would remain as an English government asset. It… Read more »
As with all negotiations, the end result will depend on relative bargaining strengths and I see no reason to assume that England would be generous.
You previously stated the Vienna Convention says debt should be split in an ‘equitable proportion’ but now you’re suggesting it might not.
No contradiction. There is no agreed definition of ‘equitable’ in this context. That is exactly what will have to be negotiated alongside all the other issues separation would raise.
Indeed but no-one can reasonably argue that an independent Wales paying for a share of Crossrail was equitable.
Always good to see the discussion and debate on here when we post opinion pieces. Appreciate all your thoughts. A few initial thoughts. First, the extended paper covers some of the issues raised in more detail. It is written for Scotland, but it applies just as much to Wales. Our main premise is that Wales could create a WCB on its own terms. If the BoE wanted a minimum balance sheet, for example, it would face a monumental challenge in removing £100bs of assets. Walse, on day one, wouldn’t face that. The same goes for the decision to pay interest… Read more »
I’m intrigued by your proposal for ‘a limited, small-balance-sheet model’. Shrinking the CB balance sheet is a proposal that usually comes from those influenced by Friedmanite monetarism, like Fed chair Kevin Warsh. That makes sense as they wish to give private banks maximum scope for money creation. But MMT theorists usually see the size of the CB balance sheet as secondary to other objectives. Indeed, limiting the balance sheet could constrain welfare much like fiscal rules do today. As you suggest, there are techniques for reducing interest payments irrespective of balance sheet size. Reliance on bond markets could… Read more »
I support the idea of a Welsh Central Bank in an independent Wales, but I would be wary of loading too many objectives onto it. Economic wellbeing ultimately depends on growing the economy, attracting investment, improving infrastructure and making better use of assets such as our diaspora and natural resources. A central bank is an important tool, but it is not a magic wand.