Support our Nation today - please donate here
Opinion

Red Line Cymru: Why the Future Generations Act means Wales must do more for Gaza 

24 Sep 2025 5 minute read
Displaced people in Gaza. Photo by hosny salah from Pixabay

Derek Walker, Future Generations Commissioner for Wales

This month, as schools reopened, it has been impossible not to think of Palestine, where it’s estimated that a classroom worth of Gaza’s children are being killed every day.

Famine has been officially declared even while food lies just a few miles from those most in need. And the mounting death toll, disease, forced displacement, and destruction continues to horrify.

A panel of experts, commissioned by the United Nations, has now concluded that the Israeli Government has committed genocide in Gaza in the time since the Hamas atrocities of 7th October 2023.

The report holds senior Israeli political and military leaders responsible and urges states across the world to take action to halt what is being called, in no uncertain terms, a crime against humanity.

Welsh Government has ‘strongly welcomed’ the report and written to UK Prime Minister, Keir Starmer, and is exploring what support it can give Gazan children in need of medical treatment.

But if Wales is to live up to its own legal and moral standards, we need to do more.

What the Well-being of Future Generations (Wales) Act 2015 demands

The Well-being of Future Generations (Wales) Act 2015 binds public bodies (our councils, health boards, government) to act in ways that ensure our decision-making stands up for the long-term, and to play their part as a globally responsible nation.

It calls for a Wales that does not just provide for the present but secures, for those who come after us, a society built on fairness, equity, health, and supported communities.

In my role as Future Generations Commissioner, I have spoken publicly several times on the need for peace and a ceasefire in Gaza, the end of suffering of all civilians and for the immediate release of all hostages.

Part of my duty is to challenge public bodies to prevent harm, and I urge every one of them, including Welsh Government, to do everything in their power to end the genocide.

Why prevention, solidarity and long-term thinking matter now

Prevention is one of the core principles of the Future Generations Act – demanding that we act before irreversible damage occurs. Allowing famine, disease, and deep destruction to unfold unchecked is against our values.

Wales has repeatedly joined international efforts to show that we see global responsibility not as optional: calling for ceasefires, insisting on essential humanitarian corridors, supporting independent investigations. Solidarity means more than words – it means asking what we can do now.

Wales must remember that decisions today have generational consequences. Nobody is safe, including the hostages, and further atrocities cannot be committed in our name.

What more Wales can, and must, do

We already see strong cross-party momentum: in the Senedd there are calls for Wales to do what it can and for recognition of Palestine as an independent state. The UK has joined six countries including Canada and France, in recognising Palestinian statehood ahead of the United Nations General Assembly in New York.

We have also seen public pressure closer to home: the Wales Pension Partnership (WPP) is being asked to divest pension funds from companies complicit in human rights abuses in Gaza.

Here are actions Wales could take:

  • Welsh Government to issue a clear, unequivocal public statement recognising the findings of the UN report and calling for an immediate humanitarian ceasefire and unimpeded aid access.
  • Review procurement contracts and public funding in Wales to ensure suppliers do not have any links with companies or supply chains complicit in violations of international law, including arms trade and settlement expansion.
  • Divest Welsh public and local authority pension funds from any firms shown to be complicit in serious human rights abuses, or operating in illegal settlements or supplying equipment used in the conflict. Cardiff Council became the first in Wales to declare its ambition to divest pension funds away from companies complicit in the war on Gaza. Monmouthshire County Council members have just agreed to scrutinise its investments.
  • Support and amplify grassroots activism: facilitate public consultations, ensure NGOs and civil society are heard; encourage public campaigns and education about the importance of global justice and international human rights.
  • And leverage symbolic and diplomatic power: recognising Palestine is a step, now Wales can put pressure on UK Government to join other governments in pressing for investigations, supporting international courts and applying moral pressure, including via boycotts in major events.

No more red lines

I support Oxfam’s Red Line for Gaza campaign. The bombing of Rafah was a red line; the killing of five-year-old Hind Rajab was a red line, the silencing by death of an estimated 189 journalists and media workers, is a red line.

Welsh public bodies’ legal and moral obligations to global responsibility do not switch off when a crisis is abroad. In a globalised world, the shape of Wales in that world matters.

A moment of truth

This is a moment that demands leadership.

All red lines have been crossed. People in Wales are making themselves heard – from the crowds supporting Dafydd Iwan draped in a Palestine flag singing Yma O Hyd at the Eisteddfod, to the Merched Cymru Dros Heddwch campaign, to the people on the Senedd steps this summer, who read out the names of an estimated 20,000 children killed in Gaza.

Let us commit, today, to being able to tell future generations we did everything we could to stop genocide.


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

17 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
David Richards
David Richards
2 months ago

We could do far more for gaza and the palestinian people as a independent nation than we ever can as the peripheral outpost of the UK we currently are. Strangely the Future Generations Commissioner completely ducks that issue.

smae
smae
2 months ago

I dispute the need for Wales to get involved here or divert funding. Wales does not have International Aid devolved to it, this is a right and duty held by Westminster. Wales should act responsibly, by ensuring that they are not contributing to the problem (buying Israeli products or exporting products to be used by Israel for example) but Wales has a limited budget, with limited tax raising powers and it’s not as if Wales is in a particularly good state economically. If the people of Wales wants to influence this matter, they should write not to their Members of… Read more »

Amir
Amir
2 months ago
Reply to  smae

That argument can also lend itself to Westminster not doing anything either. We sell arms, get money, why care about genocide and ethnic cleansing. Do nothing , say nothing, become nothing.

Undecided
Undecided
2 months ago
Reply to  smae

Agreed. No one can defend what is going on in Gaza; but this is meaningless virtue signalling. Unfortunately a hallmark of devolution and its wider network. How many extra nurses and social workers could the Commissioner’s budget fund I wonder?

Amir
Amir
2 months ago
Reply to  Undecided

How is this meaningless? Any support and solitude given for the citizens of Ghazza, who are being mercilessly killed in this horrendous genocide, is a beautiful and meaningful gesture.

Undecided
Undecided
2 months ago
Reply to  Amir

There is only one person who can stop this carnage. Trump – like him or loathe him. He is only one with any real leverage over Netanyahu, who I confidently predict has never heard of the Future Generations Act or its Commissioner. Any number of the gestures listed will make absolutely no difference.

Amir
Amir
2 months ago
Reply to  Undecided

It shows the citizens of Ghazza amd West Bank that they are not alone. The world is with them. Gestures and prayers matter. These are the holy lands and pleasing and asking Allah is all who matters.

Undecided
Undecided
2 months ago
Reply to  Amir

You are entitled to your opinion; but I would much rather see concrete action e.g. international support for the increasing opposition to Netanyahu within Israel itself. Until he is gone (preferably to The Hague) the suffering continues.

CapM
CapM
2 months ago
Reply to  smae

Of the five suggestions for action Cymru could make none refer to Welsh Government aid to Gaza. So your fear of funding being diverted is unwarranted, as far as this article goes at least. Regarding checking investments/contracts/suppliers/etc it would be good if public bodies did this as a matter of course. There would likely be a financial cost to this but ultimately it’s a moral question. I’m not convinced by the – Support and amplify grassroots activism: etc. However we should be educating citizens of all ages about the importance of global justice and international human rights. On this particular… Read more »

Amir
Amir
2 months ago
Reply to  CapM

Very true. Well said.

Bryson
Bryson
2 months ago

There needs to be diplomatic pressure on the laggard states to recognise Israel in response to the recognition of Palestine. There can be no peace in the region without this.

Amir
Amir
2 months ago
Reply to  Bryson

Fine. Tell Netanyahu and his government to stop massacring and ethnically cleansing a semitic Palestinian population. Vacate West Bank and Ghazza.

Bryson
Bryson
2 months ago
Reply to  Amir

That’s irrelevant to recognising a state, just as Hamas was irrelevant to recognising Palestine.

Amir
Amir
2 months ago
Reply to  Bryson

There will no peace until the genocide and ethnic cleansing of a semitic Palestinian population by an evil zionist government does not cease. Since you brought up Hamas. Their intent to destroy zion was always known to the evil zionist government and they still allowed money to be channelled to them despite these intentions. In order to reduce Mahmoud Abbas’s control over nothing regions. How the heck were Hamas allowed to invade zion on October 7th 2023 despite such tight security? And if the hostages were always the primary concern, how is bombing the very land they are held in… Read more »

Bryson
Bryson
2 months ago
Reply to  Amir

There are extremists in power because the moderates didn’t secure peace. But the moderate support is indeed starting to realise that the current government doesn’t care about the hostages and are stringing this out to protect their leadership and provide cover to land grab, and there will be a reckoning next election. But they’ll only be replaced by a different extreme government unless the moderates can see an alternative path to security. That’s why global recognition of Israel alongside global recognition of Palestine is the only exit from the 80 year doom loop. It’s not true that everyone wants all… Read more »

Amir
Amir
2 months ago
Reply to  Bryson

I already said “fine”. Get zion recognition by everyone. Then what, the land left for the semitic Palestinian people is now been vastly reduced. The genocide is still continuing. How is that fair? Zion gets recognised by the entire world. So does the Palestinian state. Brilliant. Except the Palestinian land is 2 tinier stripes of land separated by zion. And what about Jerusalem. Holy place to the 3 mosaic religions except it it the capital of zion and no access for the Palestinians or Muslim visitors.

CapM
CapM
2 months ago

Surely it’s the UK that ‘can’t even look after‘ our country.

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.