The politics of division has arrived in Wales – and we should be worried

Alun Smith
I haven’t read what Nigel Farage has written on his latest Substack, and I’m not going to. I’m not going to pay to read what he has to say, frankly.
I want to be informed but I’m not going to oil the wheels of his rancid machine in order to do it.
I did, however, read and watch proceedings at the Senedd on Tuesday, and, as I understand it, what Nigel Farage and Joe Martin MS have said about events over the last week or so amount to the same thing. Division. Chaos.
Two Reform UK figures, two clarion calls to racism, division and violence.
Joe Martin was confidently, but ignorantly, talking about Wales’ Nation of Sanctuary scheme and saying that it should be scrapped because most of the beneficiaries of the scheme were Ukrainian and, as yet, no Ukrainian people had attempted to behead anyone on the streets of Wales.
Dan Thomas nodded along with his minion. Smug. Superior. Sickening.
Martin warned that the scheme should be scrapped before a Sudanese man beheaded someone on a Welsh street. Hey, don’t shoot the messenger, that’s what he said.
This is the language of fascists. There is no debate to be had about that. History teaches us that.
Never mind, by the way, that prior to the election, armies of Reform voters took to social media to scream at us that the N.O.S was the vehicle used by immigrants of all colours and creeds to somehow besmirch our Cambrian homeland.
That battle was won by reasonable people pointing out the truth. Now, Reform, finally understanding that truth, have flipped it and are using it to sow yet more hate and yet more division. You couldn’t make it up. Well, you could, and they do. All the blessed time.
Jo Cox
Rhun Ap Iorwerth simply reminded the chamber that we’re currently remembering Jo Cox and her brutal murder at the hands of a Neo-Nazi, Britain First, activist. Ap Iorwerth did this whilst soberly and somewhat sadly telling the Llywydd (speaker) that he supposed we are going to have to get used to this type of contribution from the other side of the Siambr.
He reminded the chamber that Reform’s first contribution to the political life of Wales was to call for the Ukrainian flag to be removed from the Senedd, whilst also noting that the former leader of Reform in Wales was currently sitting in a very different, rather smaller chamber, on account of him accepting bribes from Ukraine’s tormentors.
In case you’re wondering if the words of these Reform figures carry any resonance, believe me, they do. I see them repeated on social media ad nauseum.
The words are like little snowballs of hate, set in motion from the top of a hill, in this case the Senedd, and they get bigger and more outlandish as they undertake their journey to the bottom of the internet.
Once there, they’re melted down and imbibed by the destitute, the desperate, the uneducated and the lost, who gulp it down, thirsty for something to cling to, something they believe validates them. Then, quenched, they beat their chests and head out into the night, angry at, they know not what, and ready to commit all manner of atrocity in the name of their freedom, in the name of their heroes.
There are other consequences too, of course. The Llwydd has issued a warning to Mr. Martin over his conduct and his language. Much more of this please Huw ( Irranca-Davies).
I understand, however, that there’s very little that the Llwydd can do about figures such as Llyr Powell, another Reform MS, who in response to the outrage over Mr. Martin’s contribution, assured us that this “is the new norm” and we should “get used to it”. Sigh.
That is the language of the bully, the narcissist, the abuser, and no, Mr.Powell, we will not “get used to it”.
The political conversation on social media has descended into a football-terrace style shouting match, where it doesn’t really matter what you believe inside, it pays no attention to the health of your moral compass, it only matters how many ‘likes’ you get and that you support your team.
Sadly, what we’ve seen in the last few weeks is that the hooliganism of social media has spilled onto our streets. The difference is, there are no real-world consequences to you leaving a laugh-emoji on my comments, but there are life-changing consequences to real-world actions. And these actions are instigated, facilitated by certain sections of our political class.
What Farage, Tice, Anderson, Thomas, Powell and Martin say today, plays out in real time tomorrow.
Pawns
They all get paid a lot of money to do it. And even they feel that they should be doing something to warrant that cheque. The problem is though, the only thing they have, the only thing they can ‘do’ is sow division and hate. That’s how they get into power and keep the money-wagon rolling.
Guys. Think about what you’re agreeing to. Think about what you’re sharing and what you’re willing to believe. You don’t have to be pawns in their little game. You don’t have to play draughts with them. You can play chess, you can be Kings and Queens and Knights.
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.


The Senedd should not tolerate racists and this member should apologise before being permitted to participate in the chamber.
It was a clear mistake by the Westminster government when they did not prosecute Farage for inciting 2 riots while jailing the rioters and proscribing Palestine action.
I agree with everything you say but the idea that Reform will see the light is a forlorn hope. Fascist rhetoric needs to be confronted where it stands.
In this particular case, I think it is ‘follow the money’.
An excellent analysis. We are no longet dealing with people who show a semblance of decency or respect. It is important that we develop a multi-agency approach to tackle these fascists : otherwise we are doomed to fall into their less than subtle traps. Leaving the chamber was playing into their hands. We must be just as nasty as they are. Rhaid i ni chwarae yn frwnt hefyd. Let’s put the boot in. Let’s expose their lack of education and career failures. The businesses they have left with debts. The underdevelop nerds and incels they have representing then. Mae’r dyddiau… Read more »
I’m with you on “multi agency” but John, no more boots. I’ve always said, the only revolution that will work will be one of the mind. We have to fight for peace. Ridiculous, I know, but if we fight war with war…all we have is…war.
What I meant was, we have to get personal with them. Expose their myriad weaknesses and dodgy backgrounds. We are not dealing with decent people here who will respond to respectful moderated debate. They feed on weakness, and we must respond accordingly.
Yes, I see your point. As Tony Benn once said..” Toughen up, bloody toughen up”.
Sadly fascism works on many levels and inevitablyit does lead to having to put the boot in, but only in defence. The trouble with fascism it that ultimatley it takes fascist methods to properly counter it.
And legging it out of the assembly when the first shots are fired is no way to win this war.
Yes, I understand your point, although I don’t think they were running away, more…voting with their feet, so to speak. We need to stand up to them but equally, we can’t allow ourselves to be dragged into their gutter. Tricky one.
Totally agree. This just gives the morons ammunition. Pc are the legitimate govt. For goodness sakes. You don’t run away. Ever. Regardless of your take on the action, it cannot happen again. PC have support from many corners, most of it borrowed, just for now while we face a common adversary. If they stomp off due to some nasty words from the naughty people, they will lose credibility So, steel yourselves, this is going to be bumpy. And all of Wales is looking to see how you react to being provoked. I want to see a backbone. Something supporters can… Read more »
Senedd! Words matter
Excellent article. The best way to defeat these sort of people is challenging them wherever they make their arguments, whether it be in the Senedd, in the press or on the streets in our communities. Do not let them go unchallenged.
Reform and Restore UK, bask in the millions donated from foreign actors. Time to declare that they are proxies for white American neoliberal interests.
To some degree I can support walking out on Reform – they live on the oxygen of publicity and are desperate attention seekers. However, PC now need a stronger strategy because you can only really pull a stunt like that once. This article is excellent and far more calmly expressed than I often find myself able when confronted by the offensive nature of these attitudes and THIS is the key!!! The yob shouts and performs and wants to provoke you to shout back because losing your temper makes it harder for you to reason and express yourself clearly. It also… Read more »