Support our Nation today - please donate here
Opinion

The UK Government: where dishonesty and cowardice meet

15 Sep 2024 7 minute read
Port Talbot steelworks. Photo Ben Birchall/PA Wire

Martin Shipton

Politicians who raise false hopes in communities, especially in the run-up to an election, are reprehensible and not to be trusted.

The outcome this week of the negotiations with Tata Steel over the company’s plan for its Port Talbot plant illustrates, I’m afraid, such dishonest behaviour well.

In cash terms, the deal accepted by the UK Government, under which two blast furnaces are shut, 2,500 jobs are lost and the company will be given £500m towards the cost of building an electric arc furnace on the site, is identical to that accepted by the previous Conservative government.

Yet senior Labour figures pulled no punches at the time in attacking the Tories.

On St David’s Day this year, when she was the Shadow Welsh Secretary, Jo Stevens said: “Steelmaking is the lifeblood of communities across Wales, the backbone of local economies and the foundation of our manufacturing capability. On St David’s Day in particular, we reflect on Wales’s proud industrial roots. Wales is brimming with potential and I am ambitious for a future fuelled by the innovation and talent I’ve seen up and down our country.

“Yet short-sighted Tory ministers look set to squander it. The deep cuts to jobs at TATA are a kick in the teeth. But ministers have compounded the risk to livelihoods, effectively forking out £500m in taxpayers’ money to make up to 3,000 people redundant and forfeit our ability to make virgin steel.

“The Business Secretary [Kemi Badenoch], not known for diplomacy, said Wales should consider this a win. The Welsh Secretary has said it’s mission accomplished on saving Welsh steelmaking.

“Their attitude shows a casual indifference to thousands of people across south Wales whose livelihoods are at stake, a fundamental misunderstanding of the regional economy, and total disregard for the need to preserve the UK’s sovereign steelmaking capability. The truth is their approach is totally self-defeating. However Tory ministers try to spin it, the loss of sovereign steelmaking is a fundamental threat to our economy and security.”

Not enough

In January, when he was standing for the leadership of Welsh Labour, Vaughan Gething, then the Economy Minister, said the UK Government’s £500m package to help Tata transition to produce more environmentally-friendly steel was not enough to save thousands of jobs.

“I think this comes down to whether the UK Government is prepared to contribute to a future of the UK steel sector,” he argued.

“Everyone knows that the economic and fiscal firepower to put into a genuine deal with a future of steel, the best deal, requires a UK Government of any type, of any colour, to invest in the future.

Mr Gething told a press conference the shedding of about 2,500 jobs was “genuinely avoidable” if the UK Government would “engage” with the Welsh Government.

Directly criticising the Tory UK government, he said: “All of us should be committed to the best deal for steel, not the cheapest deal.”

He added: “The transition that needs to take place is one that the current UK Government is not prepared to invest in to maintain that further steelmaking capacity.

“It comes down to a choice. Do you think hundreds of millions of pounds of investment is worth it to avoid thousands of job losses?

“Do you think it’s worth doing that not just to protect those jobs for a period of years into the future, but to invest into your transition to lower carbon steel? I think that is a smart bet on our future.”

Charade

Yet Tata had made it abundantly clear time and time again that the only deal acceptable to it was the one that had already been accepted by what is now the former Tory UK government. Labour politicians were well aware of that, but chose to keep the charade going. Eventually, as was inevitable, the emptiness of their supposedly tough talk was exposed when they accepted the terms of the original deal, which is now being implemented.

By pretending that a better deal could be achieved, Ms Stevens and Mr Gething were undoubtedly offering false hope to the steelworkers of Port Talbot.

In what is maybe a slightly less obvious way, Keir Starmer has been overegging his ability to gain closer economic ties for the UK with the EU without rejoining the single market or the customs union.

The European Movement UK summed up the situation well: “Just over two months into his new job, the Prime Minister’s much-hailed ‘relationship reset’ with Europe seems to be losing its sheen in Brussels. Despite many warm words and countless cheerful-looking meetings with EU leaders, it seems that the Prime Minister’s actions are indeed speaking far louder than his words.

“It was clear from the outset that an extremely close relationship with the EU, involving the likes of free movement, the single market and a customs union, were out of the question. Labour, despite bemoaning the damage of Brexit, are understandably nervous about appearing to contravene the referendum result. But the UK government seems to be adding new red lines at quite a pace, causing no small amount of alarm in Brussels.

“The refusal from the Labour government to take a publicly positive position towards rejoining [the student exchange scheme] Erasmus+ and entering a youth mobility scheme, both suggested by the EU in the last couple of months, has rather doused the fire of goodwill in Brussels. Insiders are beginning to wonder if the ‘reset’ rhetoric is just talk, with no intention of action.

“Even more concerningly for the EU, the Prime Minister’s tour of European capitals, which first appeared to simply be a relationship building exercise, is now being seen as an attempt by the UK to cut deals with individual EU member states, rather than the bloc itself. This will not be taken lightly by the EU powers, with one source describing the idea that Brussels can be circumvented as ‘completely inaccurate and legally wrong’.”

Spooked

The UK Labour government’s overriding theme is the need for economic growth. Having photo-ops with the President of France and the Chancellor of Germany may give the impression that some significant breakthrough is on the cards, but it’s all illusory. Labour seems spooked by Reform UK, and as a result is unwilling to expose how damaging Brexit has been to the economy. This is where cowardice and dishonesty meet.

Labour should be arguing the case for a return to the single market and the customs union, and in the process spiking the guns of Nigel Farage, who is currently being let off extremely lightly.

With Farage arguably the leading architect of Brexit, Starmer should be holding him to account for the obvious failure of the core policy he promoted. Instead, the subject is ignored and Farage is given carte blanche to present himself as the leader of a populist insurgency that could have a corrosive impact on Welsh politics at the Senedd election in 2026 and at the next general election three years later. Labour’s approach could prove to be a catastrophically stupid strategy.

One Labour MS I spoke to this week was more optimistic, convinced that Kamala Harris will defeat Donald Trump in November and that as a result, populism across the world will be in retreat.

It’s a nice thought, but I have serious fears that even if Harris wins, populism is here to stay until progressive governments have the courage to do what is necessary to deliver higher living standards for ordinary people.


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
14 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Brian Williams
Brian Williams
7 days ago

Fel arfer, mae Martin Shipton yn taro’r hoelen ar ei phen yn yr erthygl hon.

Robert Williams
Robert Williams
7 days ago
Reply to  Brian Williams

‘Rwy’n cytuno’n llwyr. Diolch byth am Mr Shipton!

jim
jim
7 days ago

The problem is that there is no way to significantly increase living standards for ordinary people without faster economic growth. And there is no magical way of delivering this. Though you can indeed stop doing stupid stuff – like, as Martin says, resisting re-integration with European markets, and, as Martin doesn’t say, blocking the M4 relief road.

Robert Williams
Robert Williams
7 days ago
Reply to  jim

No, Jim, NOT growth at the expense of the planet we live on.

Richard Davies
Richard Davies
7 days ago

The best solution would have been to re-nationalise the uk’s steel industry!

In addition rail, mail, water and energy utilities should all be re-nationalised.

If Mr keir starmer is a socialist, as he has claimed on many occasions, it is precisely what he would do.

It is self-evident that he is not a socialist, with the restriction of the WFA to the elderly receiving pension credit and his refusal to remove the two-child limit on Universal Credit and Tax Credits.

Ernie The Smallholder
Ernie The Smallholder
7 days ago
Reply to  Richard Davies

The problem is the UK. UK = USSR = centralised governance outside Cymru.
Only Cymru should nationalise our steel industry.

Cymru must build its own economic and political base here in Cymru.

If we cannot build our economic strength here in Cymru without our wealth leaving Cymru then we will continue to be poor.

The UK is no solution for Cymru.

Howie
Howie
7 days ago

Not going to happen with Labour in both countries.

Martyn Vaughan
Martyn Vaughan
7 days ago

Being afraid to attack Farage over Brexit will prove to be serious mistake. The Closed List system for Senedd voting guarantees a substantial Reform presence in the chamber. It is no wonder people have lost faith in politics when politicians reveal themselves to be either mendacious or inept. Or both.

Ernie The Smallholder
Ernie The Smallholder
7 days ago

The problem is that Cymru is still subservient to the UK state and this will never change while our own people still vote at elections for those parties based outside Cymru. The Cymru government at Cardiff Bay still doesn’t have total control of our taxation, budgets, economy, our police and justice etc. We as nation Cymru should stop believing that the solution is in the UK because it isn’t. The UK has deceived Cymru again and again, and taken our hard earned income in taxation without any return. The EU, however, would be continuing to give us investment grants t… Read more »

Neil Anderson
Neil Anderson
7 days ago

I agree, Ernie the Smallholder, but once independent, we will have our own fiat currency – and won’t need a stock exchange.

Y Cymro
Y Cymro
6 days ago

Thanks to the English Conservatives who with Tory tyrant Margaret Thatcher in the 80s sold off the family jewels meaning once nationalised industries are now owned by foreign countries. Germany would never do similar, and why they are still a world power when it comes to manufacturing. Imaging BMW, Volkswagen, Daimler being foreign owned lol. Never. Imagine chemical giant Siemens being owned & run by an American CEO. Wouldn’t happen seeing 118,000 German workers are employed. Blue Labour are no better than Thatcher in my eyes. They’ve just copy & pasted Conservative ideology preferring to stick a Union Jack Labour… Read more »

Ianto
Ianto
6 days ago

It is not beyond the realm of possibility that we see a Tory-Reform English nationalist main opposition in our Senedd gnawing at our democracy, gagging for us to revert to complete colonial status.

Colin Mann
Colin Mann
6 days ago

i agree with the comments below that say that independence for Cymru is the only answer. We are not even an afterthought in Westminster

Keith Davies
Keith Davies
23 minutes ago

How could Reform be any more corrosive to Wales than Labour has been since devolution.
You call Reform a populist party, and I suppose that is accurate, given that their policies are popular with nearly everyone who has had enough of the rancid politics of the Labour party.
You really need to put your bitterness about Brexit behind you now, it’s becoming tiresome.

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.