Opinion

Complaints about ‘sleaze’ at Westminster ring hollow – they’re just not trying to hide it anymore

04 Nov 2021 5 minutes Read
Westminster at sunset

Ifan Morgan Jones

The sudden outburst of concern by opposition parties in the wake of the Owen Paterson lobbying row that there is something rotten in the Palace of Westminster rings rather hollow.

The funny thing about the whole lobbying scandal is that the rules are so incredibly lax to begin with. Despite committing an “egregious” breach of lobbying rules, Owen Paterson was only facing a 30-day suspension.

A quick look at Hansard will show that before yesterday, Owen Paterson had for years quite frequently gone stretches of three to nine months without speaking in the Commons at all.

The only thing that changed yesterday – and made the main opposition parties react with fake alarm – was that the government stopped pretending to care about MPs lobbying as a problem.

Rather than just not doing anything about lobbying, Westminster wasn’t even pretending to bother to do anything about lobbying.

The government were comfortable enough in power with their 80 seat majority that they didn’t really care who knew that the rules were drawn up and dropped to suit themselves.

But if parties really were serious about getting to grips with the issue, they would not allow MPs to take second jobs at all.

If someone wants to carry on being a GP, fine. But what possible justification is there for an MP, elected to serve their constituents, to take on multiple roles with different private businesses?

How can that not be a distraction at best, and a conflict of interest at worst? They should be there to represent their constituents and that should be their one and only priority.

Despite this, nearly one in five MPs take on regular paid work outside Westminster.

I don’t remember any one of the big three parties campaigning to change this.

The rot – both figurative and literal, given that Westminster is quite famously falling down – is now so seeped into the foundations of the building that they’re part and parcel of the whole edifice.

Abhorrent

If you think the House of Commons is bad, have you met the House of Lords? Here party donors are directly elevated to non-elected positions crafting our legislation.

Just in the last decade, people who have donated a combined £50.4m to the three main political parties have been given peerages.

There really is no need for brown envelopes when this system operates in plain sight, everyone knows about it and no one seems to see it as a problem.

Although they may hold their nose at current events in the House of Commons, all the main UK-wide political parties have been complicit in the continuation of this system.

You would think that having a non-elected second chamber would be enough of an aberration against democracy in itself. In any other country it would be rightly considered to be the mark of a banana republic.

But a non-elected second chamber where you can, with enough millions, effectively buy your way in is particularly abhorrent.

But Westminster gets away with it because the rules have developed in such a higgledy-piggledy way over centuries that no one has to take responsibility for the status quo.

That’s why Westminster looks like a medieval palace despite only being built 150 years ago. That’s why it’s full of deliberately complex, unwritten conventions that can be dropped when amenable to those with power.

It’s ‘tradition’ and we have to be ‘very careful’ about ‘cross-party reform’. This is code for ‘actually this system suits up very well so we’re not going to do anything about it’.

The whole point of the ‘ancient’ persona of the parliament is not to change and in not to change to retain power within the hands of a particular wealthy elite.

Carbuncle

Can Westminster reform itself? Probably not. Because anyone wielding power at Westminster has won as a result of the way Westminster currently operates.

The main attraction of Welsh and Scottish independence is that it’s the one kind of reform of Westminster that doesn’t involve Westminster at all.

It’s a surgery in which this blackened, corrupted carbuncle is just cut off in one fell swoop, from without.

The Welsh and Scottish Parliament are already more functional and democratic than Westminster has ever been.

They do have their problems. Both they and their governments have recently had very high profile issues with their own standards committees. They require detailed scrutiny – from their own politicians and the media – that particularly in Wales isn’t always there.

But they at least have proportional representation. They do not have unelected second chambers. They have a modern, forward-thinking attitude to technological reform.

They’re not perfect. But at least seem to function, to a certain extent, in the interests of the public.

This is more than could currently be said at Westminster, which increasingly seems to serve as a thin veneer of democracy for those who wish to wield power, with what few rules there are changed at a whim to suit themselves.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
12 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Steve George
Steve George
23 days ago

Just for the record, the Senedd’s electoral system is not “proportional”. e.g. Labour circa 38% votes but 50% of seats. That’s not to say it isn’t preferable to the Westminster system but it certainly isn’t proportional.

GW Atkinson
GW Atkinson
23 days ago

There is absolutely no accountability at Westminster. It’s a corrupt talking shop for the rich and privileged. This is why we need independence from this joke of a parliament. Bunch of self serving, greedy lying sh1ts. No politicians should be allowed a 2nd job, it goes against everything that a democratic parliament is meant to represent.

I’m a Welshman, get me out of here!!!

Y Cymro
Y Cymro
23 days ago

Westminster is corrupt to its core. A racist & anti-Welsh English parliament used to oppress not only Wales still but the world in its day.

The fascist Conservatives are so arrogant they don’t even hide the fact that they are crooks anymore. And if anyone thinks it’s a system that can be fixed are deluding themselves and doing Wales a disservice. Time we got shot of this Westminster white elephant!

#YesCymru 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿. #Ymlaen 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿 #Unionism 🇬🇧👎;#Westminster 🇬🇧 👎 #ConservativesAreToxic 🇬🇧 ☢️☣️

Arwyn
Arwyn
23 days ago

Further evidence that the UK is the Tory state if we even needed it. I think “the Welsh Conservatives” is a misnomer. The only thing they want to conserve is the political hegemony of the British upper class. Their political ideology is destroying Wales. They should call themselves “the radical British National Party, Wales regional branch” if they want to be accurate. The worst aspect of Welsh Labour Unionism is that it enables Tory British Nationalism. Their pursuit of federalism is an attempt to reach an accomodation with the Westminster political establishment. Only independence rids us of the Tory State.… Read more »

Erisian
Erisian
23 days ago
Reply to  Arwyn

Welsh Conservative: In the vast majority of cases – not just a misnomer but an oxymoron.

Welsh_Siôn
Welsh_Siôn
23 days ago
Reply to  Erisian

… populated by morons who deserve as little oxy(gen) as possible.

hdavies15
hdavies15
23 days ago

I see Paterson has quit with the usual comments about the unfairness of it all ! The man was drawing a full M.P’s salary yet had no qualms taking even more from businesses whose interests he lobbied with government departments. Tories said that his “offence” was not proven but it sure looks like a crock of sh*t from where I’m sitting. At least he can now go off and do his 2nd job full time.

Steve Duggan
Steve Duggan
23 days ago

Nothing will ever change in Westminster, too many benefit from the corruptness.Upon independence we can change things for the better.

Grayham Jones
22 days ago

Stop being little Englanders and be proud to be welsh kick all English party’s out of wales 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿 it’s time for a new wales 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿

Malcolm rj
Malcolm rj
22 days ago

Neal kinock spend most of his time saying that the house of lords should be scrapped he is now a lord himself say no more

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.